Namor [with Cap's shield] vs Hercules [without mace]

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Philosophía
Who wins?

Fight takes place in the rain, but there's no body of water nearby for Namor to drag Hercules into.

zopzop
Namor doesn't need the shield. Namor wins because of comparable physical stats but MUCH greater mobility.

TethAdamTheRock
I think Hercules is Much Stronger than Namor

leonidas
he's def in a different class despite their 'battles' most of which are nothing more than sparring matches. depends how effectively you see namor using the shield. i'd say of the 2 herc is the more skilled for sure. i could see him disarming namor tbh. not sure the shield makes that big a difference given that namor would hardly be proficient with it. i'd still take herc for a majority here. shield may get namor an extra win maybe. mobility isn't much of a factor to me because namor would have to close with herc anyway so his mobility goes out the window because to win he has to fight h2h. /shrug

celeyhyga17
thumb up

flight not really an advantage. if he had ranged attacks to go along with it, big factor.

h1a8
Good fight. If Namor can be proficient at the shield then he wins, otherwise Herc wins.

Smurph
I don't see their classes of strength as all that different, especially given some of Namor's higher showings. I also think Cap's shield could be a determining factor here.

Namor ftw, 6-7/10

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by leonidas
he's def in a different class

Yeah, as he doesn't have half the feats Namor has.

Herc gets his head torn off stick out tongue

Genii96
Namor doesn't need the shield, he is just as strong as Hercules on Land and has better mobility

zopzop
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Yeah, as he doesn't have half the feats Namor has.

Herc gets his head torn off stick out tongue
All kidding aside, Namor does have suspect durability against concentrated heat attacks. Luckily that's not something Hercules is capable of reproducing (with or without the mace).
Originally posted by Genii96
Namor doesn't need the shield, he is just as strong as Hercules on Land and has better mobility
Nah, on land I'd give the advantage to Hercules BUT the OP said it's in raining in this fight. Depending on writer, the rain either invigorates him (see the BRB fight) or at least sustains him but he still needs to visit the ocean to be at 100%(see the old Thor fight). So assuming both fighters are starting in good condition, Namor is golden here.

TethAdamTheRock
Hercules one shotted Wonderman who is as strong as namor

Genii96
Originally posted by zopzop
All kidding aside, Namor does have suspect durability against concentrated heat attacks. Luckily that's not something Hercules is capable of reproducing (with or without the mace).

Nah, on land I'd give the advantage to Hercules BUT the OP said it's in raining in this fight. Depending on writer, the rain either invigorates him (see the BRB fight) or at least sustains him but he still needs to visit the ocean to be at 100%(see the old Thor fight). So assuming both fighters are starting in good condition, Namor is golden here.

His suit fixed his dehydration problem didn't it? Or is he in speedos here?

Genii96
Originally posted by TethAdamTheRock
Hercules one shotted Wonderman who is as strong as namor

A WW2/adolescent namor bear WM and Ares at the same time, used wonderman as a bat to smack Ares too

TethAdamTheRock
Wonderman is stronger than Namor

Genii96
Tell that to on panel showings between the two, WM couldn't even balance hydrobase himself

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by TethAdamTheRock
Wonderman is stronger than Namor

Based on...?

Well? I'm waiting to hear. Go on, Colossus.

TethAdamTheRock
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Based on...?

Well? I'm waiting to hear. Go on, Colossus. His fight with thor and red hulk...

h1a8
Originally posted by Smurph
I don't see their classes of strength as all that different, especially given some of Namor's higher showings. I also think Cap's shield could be a determining factor here.

Namor ftw, 6-7/10 They are somewhat different. The key is to consider Thing. Namor is a peer to Thing. Thing is not quite a peer to Hercules.

Genii96
Namor has omeshotted thing several times

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.