Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Basically in a nutshell this is Anakin Skywalker at the beginning of RotS, as a fully fledged adherent to Jedi principles, versus Darth Vader after being anointed a Sith Lord, but still with his arms and legs, basically when he fought Obi-Wan Kenobi.

MF Vader is more powerful. So he should win.

Anakin at the end of RotS is more powerful due to the fact that he used rage.

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
Anakin at the end of RotS is more powerful due to the fact that he used rage. do you think Anakin as a Jedi might be spurred on by seeing the monster he could become, and this might lead him to a "Force enlightenment" letting him win? What if Darth Vader becomes emotionally distraught at trying to kill himself

Is there any evidence for that claim

RotS Novelization, if you mean that.

Anakin was beating Dooku onto the floor even in TCW, the idea he needs to be a Sith adherent to defeat Dooku seems unsupported in my eyes, but feel free to cite evidence to the opposite conclusion.

Dooku defeated ObixWon and later in the movie Obi defeated Anakin.

The only way Anakin would have defeated Dooku would have been to tap into his anger.

It is logic really.

Now you're comparing apples to orange to grapefruit obviously as a SORESU adherent Kenobi would be able to defeat Vader, who is a cocky overconfident Sith version of Anakin who is already reckless, whereas Dooku is more of a stoic, wise old man who doesn't take risks, Kenobi cannot exploit him. But Because Anakin and Vader are both with a superhero movie physique and using a strong style they would be better suited to smashing Dooku even if he makes no obvious flaws or mistakes. One might say Dookus biggest flaw was trying to fight Anakin at all instead of just fleeing altogether, and living off of dividends and equity in Serenno.

Great post!

I will give my response in a hour or so.

thank you, I look forward to a highly intellectual discussion between two equals

Thank you.

You the same.

Sorry it is taking so long transfer, I am quite busy.

I will try to have it by tonight sometime.

MF Vader is much more powerful.

What is MF and where is your evidence good ser?

I am going to prepare a powerful response to your reasoned arguments. Until we meet again, friend!

I am both pleased and horrified!

Ani presses a button and Vader suffocates.