The more scared he gets, the stronger he gets. What writer did that weird thing. I've been completely underestimating colossus. He's been an x-man since he was a teen and his fighting abilities are probably higher than emil. I know they train russian spies well, but not the kind of enemies the x-men fight. 5/10 either way.
Key thing here is how much stronger does Abom get? Ok, we know he may get stronger due to adrenaline, but so does 95% of comic characters. We've seen Colossus while enraged so that was his adrenaline. Abomination starts off at a higher strength level than Hulk, but soon gets passed and defeated. Abom and Colossus may very well be on the same strength level. Abomination does have the high healing factor/regeneration abilities, but Colossus doesnt have to worry about being cut or anything of the sorts. Plus because he doesnt have to breathe, it takes a long time for him to tire.
Colossus skin/body is more durable so i think hed take punishment much better than Abomination. If Abomination were to keep getting stronger like his other gamma counterpart, hed take it, but i just dont see it happening.
When Abomination FIRST fought Hulk, he beat the living sh t out of him. Really. In their rematch Hulk did better... but...
Anyways.. Emil Bronsky.. Has high durability, but I think Colussus is higher.. Bronsky is gonna be slower than Piotr, but has that healing factor.. Colossus doesn't regularly fight muscletypes... Emil does.. a lot.. but not a guy with training... hrm...
I'd say tie. 5/10 Either guy has the capability of putting down the other.
__________________ Quotes from Hia8:
"I claimed that the science is sometimes faulty."
"You don't understand. This is fiction. That means none of this stuff really happened."
"There is no writer to purposely ignore a character's natural ability just because it suits the story."
"in some cases because the writer knows that Character A will dominate Character B easily and refuses to allow this to happen for the sake of the story."
Don't take my word for it . I'm a newbie to KMC and comics. Maybe you should see what veteran hulk and colossus fans have to say before making it classic or half powered.