Colossus, however, Star takes a few due to her flight abilities, she can BFR him. He's stronger and more durable though, and he can more than likely tank her energy blasts.
I think the field favors Starfire.
She can just fly and bomb the whole area.
But if Colossus can withstand the attacks and SF decides to go h2h she loses.
I 'm leaning towards Colossus unless SF really turns up the heat.
I'd say she's a better h2h combatant than he is. She lacks the multitude of feats he has but she was written to be warrior princess from birth. She's been portrayed to be a better melee fighter than Donna for years. Donna herself being able to make Wonder Woman work for wins.
Resurrecting a really old thread, but Starfire won an Amazonian tournament comprised of nearly every Amazon on the island (excluding Diana, Donna, and Artemis).
one of which starfire is missing in large quantities unlike the amazonian warriors...
she might be competent but she sure as hell isnt on the same lvl as the amazonians if she won it has more to do with her physiology then her being better skilled then them.
Starfire was born and raised a warrior since birth among an entire race of powerful warriors.
Not as skilled as Amazons? Donna Troy is definitely in the top class of the Amazonian skill bracket and Starfire always beat Donna in sparring two out of three times. This was stated on panel during a sparring session in which Starfire, you know, won.