This is barely a versus.
None of them are trying to "replace" Batman, which is the most popular variation of this type of question.
Cap, BP and DD would keep the status quo fine.
lol @ Gotham being more dangerous than Marvel NY, that might go for the average citizen but not for heros, actually the reason why Gotham is so dangerous is because there's only the Bat Family protecting it. If Supes would decide to X-Ray Vision scan the city and blitz dash all villains to dust it would happen in like 1 hour.
Marvel NY is the center of earth/universe threatening events like each 2 weeks and full of villains that would outright murder Batman.
__________________
I am in your algorithm learning all your mannerisms
I'm already level with God
A million words a second and I know your imperfections, baby
I'm the only future you've got
Speak in diatonics, motivation diabolic
I'm like a religion, better locked in a box
Picture perfect image, more powerful every minute, baby
I am everything that you're not
If marvel NY heroes were any good at their job they would have eliminated kingpin decades ago. But they cant despite the Avengers, Xmen, fantastic 4, shield, spidey, cap, dd, punisher etc...
In Gotham guys like Red Hood would murder Punisher. And do it easily.
Not to mention the Society of Supervillans have been known to have a base there.
Poison Ivy, Clayface, Manbat, BANE, black market Amazo androids, League of Assassins, Court of Wolverines (Owls). All of whom would be too much for these guys without Batmans brain.
__________________ Batman officially defeats Wolverine.
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f105/t562753.html
(please log in to view the image) > everyone you listed
I can't believe you're serious that Batman's villain roster is > pretty much all of marvel because NY just is the basic playground for events etc.
Hell Spider-Man's villain roster alone trumps Batman's in all possible ways except maybe that the hero requires detective skills...
and none of the main villains were assassinated for the same reason Batman's still live...
__________________
I am in your algorithm learning all your mannerisms
I'm already level with God
A million words a second and I know your imperfections, baby
I'm the only future you've got
Speak in diatonics, motivation diabolic
I'm like a religion, better locked in a box
Picture perfect image, more powerful every minute, baby
I am everything that you're not
Last edited by Parmaniac on Aug 7th, 2014 at 05:09 PM
I am in your algorithm learning all your mannerisms
I'm already level with God
A million words a second and I know your imperfections, baby
I'm the only future you've got
Speak in diatonics, motivation diabolic
I'm like a religion, better locked in a box
Picture perfect image, more powerful every minute, baby
I am everything that you're not
No prep? Is that even possible? I mean they're not going to just walk into Gotham and start fighting..are they? What are they going to do when they're ressting? So they're not allowed to make any plans? Not sure I'm getting this thread.
Looks like marvel stomps to me.
__________________ Watch what people are cynical about, and one can often discover what they lack.
- General George Patton Jr