Anakin would oWn. Even in AOTC he was a better swordsman then his own master.
All Luke was a master of in ROTJ was the 00ber 1337 'Ninja Scream'...
Luke would get owned in a matter of seconds by AOTC Annie. If Anakin would hang with Dooku (one of THE best swordsman in the galaxy) for a good time, then Luke stands absolutely no chance. Plus Anakin has more force potential, and had spent roughly 10-11 years learning how to use it, as well as spent that time practicing a REAL lightsaber style and had got pretty damn good at it.
This fight is wierd for the fact that Luke is older than his father
Anakin was 19 in AOTC, Luke is 22 or so in ROTJ. Still a weird situation, but Anakin's not quite older.
Luke takes Anakin. Anakin didn't necessarily have more force potential. Now, he probably did, but there is nothing that says that Luke could have a greater potential.
Anakin has more training, but Luke was trained to be a weapon and was trained much more quickly. Do you really think Obi-wan had Anakin using the force to hold objects in the air within a day or two of beginning his training? Why do you think Obi-wan and Yoda didn't tell Luke about his father? Because Luke was in training to be weapon against Vader and the Emperor.
There also is zero proof that Vader faked the fight with Luke in ROTJ. For most of the fight, in the beginning parts, Luke was holding back as he didn't want to fight Vader, but he actually wanted to turn him back to the Lightside of the Force. Why would Vader want to turn Luke to the Darkside at that time? If he did so, he would die. We know Vader didn't want to die, but instead kill the Emperor. He couldn't do that if he was dead.
Luke wins.
__________________ http://darthglentract.tripod.com/index.html Go Jawa's!!
Actually Vader talks about turning Luke to the dark side and overthrowing the Emperor only moments before he arrives at the death star at the start of ROTJ. I doubt his opinion changed in days, when it couldn't in months. Also Luke may have trained faster then others because of the time, but still days don't make up for years.
Because being defeaten in a fight doesn't mean you die... He wanted Luke to give in to his anger when he has done that, he is stopped and bam you have a new Dark Side apprentice.
Vader probably for some reason figured the rule of two would be over from that moment one because the Sith had already won, Dooku believed it would end soon enough too when he was still in command of the seperatist army's... He really didn't expect to die, just hoped to get Luke angry enough to turn him to the Dark Side.
Really, how would letting Luke win accomplish anything? It wouldn't. Luke is good, or Vader is an idiot. You pick. I'm a fanboy? Phh. People like you amuse me. Luke hater.
(@:Anomaly.)
__________________
Last edited by Ermac_Master on Feb 27th, 2006 at 07:47 PM
Luke has 6 months of training, but we saw that Luke was doing things in the first day or two that Anakin wouldn't have been doing for weeks, if not months(lifting mutiple objects with the force at the same time). We also know that Luke was trained to be a weapon to defeat Vader and the Emperor. Anakin was trained to keep the peace.
with more raw force potential.
A totally unproven assumption. Why couldn't Luke have more force potential then Anakin?
and no lightsaber training at all..
Luke began training with a lightsaber in the first hour or two of his training. Luke continued to train at Ben's house for months after that. Luke has also engaged in more real lightsaber duels then Anakin and is more experince in that department.
Random side note, Luke has the Kaiburr crystal, which increases his force power by a little.
__________________ http://darthglentract.tripod.com/index.html Go Jawa's!!
Feb 27th, 2006 03:16 AM
http://darthglentract.tripod.com/index.html Go Jawa's!!
