I don't think anyone has broken his guard when he was a Soresu master... but I think Sidious might be able to do it. Sidious pwns with force powers though.
Sidious, with some difficulty. Considering he wiped out three Jedi Masters in seconds, one who rivaled Obi-Wan himself, I don't see him losing this. Kenobi would give him hell with his Soresu mastery, but I don't see him actually winning.
Registered: May 2005
Location: somewhere over the rainbow
Sidious, though not by much, he was able to destroy three of the council's most powerful masters, he's the dark side equivelant(well he's not equal but he's quite close to) Yoda, who in fact told obi-won himself that he couldn't stand up to sids.
__________________ The whole world trembles in fear before my awesome unholy army of garden gnomes soon we will rule the world and from there...home depot!!!
Registered: Nov 2005
Location: Seminole Country, FL
Account Restricted
I think what Yoda told Obiwan implied that overall Obi Wan will never be powerful enough to defeat Sidious. However judging by the saber abilities I would say Obiwan could take this. Sidious didn't exactly impress me with his saber abilities, I'd think even Anakin could take him..
__________________
Facts, the Anti Fanboy solution
I think Sidious takes this. Kit was about as good as Obi-wan and Sidious killed him in seconds. Obi-wan will last longer the Kit, I think, but he doesn't stand a chance of winning.
__________________ http://darthglentract.tripod.com/index.html Go Jawa's!!
Registered: May 2005
Location: somewhere over the rainbow
If that's the case how does yoda(a much much better swordsman then obi-won) not chop sidious into kibble n bits? Sidious even had dooku(who in my opinion would wreck obi in a fight) subservient to him. To be fair even if you're not a sidious fan he either beat(some would say survived) a dual with yoda who's far better, killed three jedi masters all rivaling obi in skill in a blink and had dooku, arguably superior to obi subservient to him.
__________________ The whole world trembles in fear before my awesome unholy army of garden gnomes soon we will rule the world and from there...home depot!!!
Registered: Nov 2005
Location: Seminole Country, FL
Account Restricted
Dooku is a better duelist than Sidious. Yoda is a better duelist than Dooku. I retract my previous statement. I was thinking that obiwan beat anakin, anakin can beat Sidious, so Obiwan can beat Sidious, but that argument is obviously faulty.. Sidious would take Obiwan in a hard fight.
__________________
Facts, the Anti Fanboy solution
Registered: May 2005
Location: somewhere over the rainbow
is that sarcasm? To be fair sidious pwned yoda who pwned dooku who got rocked by anakin whose equal in all but intelligence to obi, so sidious>yoda>ob1
__________________ The whole world trembles in fear before my awesome unholy army of garden gnomes soon we will rule the world and from there...home depot!!!
Registered: Nov 2005
Location: Seminole Country, FL
Account Restricted
Sidious didn't pwn Yoda. Sidious and Yoda stalemated with Sidious having the upper ground the whole fight, so logically if it was on the same level, Yoda would have beaten Sidious. And actually Yoda was winning at the end of the fight, as you see Sidious and his "Oh shit im screwed" look. Yoda didn't pwn Dooku but he would have, and Dooku is a far better duelist than Sidious.
__________________
Facts, the Anti Fanboy solution
Registered: May 2005
Location: somewhere over the rainbow
scratch that
__________________ The whole world trembles in fear before my awesome unholy army of garden gnomes soon we will rule the world and from there...home depot!!!
Last edited by Darth_Frobo on Mar 14th, 2006 at 11:26 PM
Registered: May 2005
Location: somewhere over the rainbow
Truth be told, Even if yoda is more powerful, dooku isn't he would have tried to usurp the sith if he was, end of story. As for yoda, sidious outsmarted him and used his ressources to his advantage better then yoda, in the end he caught a lucky break but again it doesn't matter as this is a saber dual not a force power dual.
__________________ The whole world trembles in fear before my awesome unholy army of garden gnomes soon we will rule the world and from there...home depot!!!
Mar 14th, 2006 08:50 PM
http://darthglentract.tripod.com/index.html Go Jawa's!!
