Ok man...Thor and martianmanhunter are in the same ball park. Regular Thor. If you throw in two other Thors who are vastly superior to Thor its gonna be spite of epic proportions. So just stick to regular Thor with theses types of guys bro
Regular Thor has had pretty impressive mental resistance feats. His instance of being mindraped by Moondragon - which generally is the example most people use to gauge Thor's mental defenses - is off set by the times he's resisted psychic assaults.
Thor's best is beyond J'onn's best, so, yeah, if J'onn happened to phase, speedblitz, use telepathy, and amp his physical attributes all at once - which I doubt as I can't recall anytime J'onn ever fought like that in the pages of a comic, I have no doubt Thor could and would beat him for the majority.
Not when he can amp. He's already faced the entire League and made Apollo look like a fool. Not to mention he can absorb the planet for more power. And I doubt he can resist MM telepathy. If he can put down Spectre, he can put down Thor.
And Thor's feats are clearly above J'onn's. There's a handful of people in the herald tier who can tie or beat Thor in the "feat war" game, and Martian Manhunter is not one of them.
He's resisted the likes of Rachel and Phoenix amped Emma, Loki amped Sandu, Odin, the Twilight Sword amped Morgan Le Fay who warped reality, and Glory, a being comprised of tens of thousands of gods.
So yes, he has the mental feats - plenty, actually - to ward off J'onn.
And MM has taken down the League and Spectre. He has high feats for himself. I just don't Thor lasting against someone with all those powers. And it seems MM is using them more intelligently lately.
If anything that would count towards a fluke or slim chance of victory J'onn has.
In a direct confrontation, even with telepathy involved, J'onn is getting destroyed by King Thor, especially later on in the Reigning. Thor was arrogant, but when he wanted people dead, they died.
No, it was a teaser of MM battling the DCnU JL. Phasing parts of his body, hanging with Superman, etc... I believe MM went up against multiple members of the JLA as well. I don't think Thor can hang with all the members of DCnU JL, anyway.
Seems to me you're using both pre-Flashpoint and DCnU J'onn feats to make your case. I'm not opposed to either one being debated here, but you can't have it both ways.
In any case, Thor's high end feats are clearly and obviously greater than those of Manhunter's. He has high end feats, sure, but not on Thor's level.
If they were being jobbed out and fighting under ninja law like the League does to put over whomever they're fighting, I don't see why he couldn't, especially with the massive AoE attacks he has at his disposal.
MM would just phase through most of Thor's attacks. MM even gave Adam pause with his TP, I see no different vs Thor, especially after some of MM most powerful TP feats.
And some of the JLA couldn't do anything, because he was phasing. Not the first time MM restrained the JL solo,