Gender: Male Location: 4th Street Underpass, Manhattan
It either comes down to Ang Lee Hulk and his tank toss, or Ruffalo Hulk and his Leviathan punch. Both have massive damage soak as well, with Bana tanking a mini-nuke, and Hulk tanking the Chitauri Armada's blasts.
Norton Hulk was clearly the most "human" of them all. His feats were a lot smaller. Even his jumps were modest in comparison to the other two. He was more of a parkour guy than a guy who just hops across deserts and cities.
Avengers Hulk was by far the most powerful IMO, and without a doubt the strongest (nearly destroyed that giant worm thing with one huge punch, and then held it up in the air).
He also knocked Thor several feet with a bro-fist, no small task.
Ang Lee Hulk can run much faster, I think his top speed was 300 mph. That's about the only advantage I can think of... I mean he was having trouble fighting off a mutant poodle for God's sake.
I think a really competitive fight would be Ultimate Destruction Hulk (video game) vs Avengers Hulk. I think I'd pick UD Hulk to win, honestly. Total savage.
Well the Leviathan punch was a great feat, but it's own size and halt in it's momentum were what made it flip over. Not to take away from Hulk's accomplishment in that scene.
As for the Gamma Dogs, they attacked him and it was clear that Ang Lee Hulk gets angry/bigger and that increases his strength and durability. Remember he grew so big he snapped one of their jaws just because it was trying to bite him.
I re-watched the scene (amazing scene btw), and I thought I remembered Hulk lifting the leviathan (just learned what the name of it was btw, lol) up, but I was wrong.
However, the way he literally stopped it in it's tracks was far more impressive than anything Bana did, imo. That thing was massive, and could have easily plowed through a skyscraper.
Ang Lee's Hulk was much faster, he was literally running circles around the army, and a bonus feature on the DVD said that he could run 300 mph. Not sure how that's going to help him in a fight, I don't know how agile he was (been a long time since I've seen the movie).
This wouldn't really be an easy fight for either of them, seeing as how they'd both just keep getting angrier and continue fighting. I do think Ruffalo would be getting the better of it though, at least until Bana grows so large that he can just step on Ruffalo. Ruffalo seemed to be stronger and more powerful, but he also seemed to be the more skilled fighter. You have to remember, Ruffalo was fighting off Loki's army, while Bana just had to deal with the regular ol' US army for the most part.
And I could be wrong about this, but wasn't Ruffalo's Hulk being controlled by Banner in the New York scene? I know he willingly transformed into the Hulk, but I'm not quite sure if he was actually in control of Hulk's actions. That could be a big advantage... intelligence and power is a dangerous combination.
Banner was defiantly in control, transforming on will and taking orders from Captain America. Banner or Norton hulk where only semi controlled through Betty to bring him back to a calm state.
Also Banner Hulk fought his gamma mutated father in the end and survived the gamma nuke. So hes got some serious durability.
The only thing Norton hulk did feat wise imo was KO the abomination. Not an easy feat but he did it.
__________________ Don't play games with me General
Bana Hulk was the fastest and could leap the furthest. He also has the greatest strength feats.
But Ruffalo Hulk has shown the most powerful punches.
If I had to choose I'd say Bana simply because we flat out see him get bigger and stronger through a fight, and we saw his Wolverine level healing factor in action.