Well, Sidious did this was ease, killing Kit while fending off Mace, and Yoda's only just weaker than Sidious so I don't see why he couldn't, especially with Mace not being there. He should be able to do it even more easily than Sidious did, since Mace isn't there. But if you disregard what happened in ROTS and just use EU versions of the three Jedihe's up against it's closer but Yoda still wins.
Registered: Feb 2006
Location: Reading Harry Potter
Okay, take this realistically. Yoda would probably handle this different from Sidious. Take the background, style and skills from all three opponents and apply it to this battle. I don't think Sidious defeating with that type of ease was too realistic. Realistically, I would say Yoda would win but not easily. And certainly not as easily as Sidious own.
He used something akin to Ataru. But, I suppose being larger and taller than Yoda - he wouldn't need (nor would he have the space) to flip around as much.
And, Yoda was the master of Ataru. I'd say he still takes this, even with Mace.
I think many of you are underestimating the Jedi's potential. Having said that though, Yoda will most likely win -- but not without a struggle. However, and with fanboyism aside, I see Kit being Yoda's main threat here. Overall, he's shown us much more impressive feats than the other two Jedi, and his natural physical abilities would definitely provide more of a challenge. Perhaps these reasons could contribute as to why he put up a greater fight than the other two when up against Sidious?
Another thing I'd like to point out is that, prior to the Emperor revealing his blade and displaying his immense prowess, the Jedi really had no idea of what they were up against. Here, however, they are going head to head with someone they have known their whole lives. Chances are, they've seen or at least have an idea of how Yoda fights, to be able to at least know how to react (unlike when fighting the Emperor) - right?
Yoda could just Force Push the Strike Team and then speedblitz them as they get up. Yoda is either equal or superior to Sidious, who barely moved a blade to kill these guys.
__________________ "Happiness is a lie. Life is horror. The light is always dying all across the universe. The last star will flicker out someday, when it does, all that remains is shadow. And I will be its king!"'-Amahl Farouk
Yoda wins, I heard he was able to face off against three similarly skilled masters unarmed (Though IIRC he didn't defeat them, just evaded their attacks.)