Registered: Feb 2005
Location: Hiding from zombies
In a straight up fight? Probably. I wouldn't dismiss the possibility. My thoughts on it come from watching the two fight. Obi has a tighter defense and better reflexes. Qui Gon leaves himself open a lot and has a horrid defense.
LOL, yeah, and Anakin with one arm and no lightsaber was stronger than Sidious
She's strong, but as we saw at the end she's really not much of a match for Mace. he was injured and wasn't even trying to win but still won.
Well, seeing as we've not seen TPM Mace fight it's cannon.
1) Yeah, Mace sailed through the battle of Geonosis and killed Fett. More like ran at him and merely sliced off his head, something Jinn would have no problem doing.
2) Jango the dealiest man in the galaxy? Talk about hyperbole.
3) Yeah, Mace did do some training and di improve a lot.
Anoon Bondara, who's said to be the strongert Jedi in the galaxy in terms of saber skills? Personally I'm not even sure if Depa's capably of defeating him, definately not in 3 seconds.
Janus, you don't get it do you. For one thing in over 850 years as a Jedi surley he hasd dueled several combatants. And I never said Depa was weak for never being in a real duel I merely stated the fact that Maul has more dueling experience. And their's no point argueing in less you can present me with some people Depa has dueled in a real duel.
Yes. Depa.
Nevertheless, a way lamer way to die than at the hands of Padawan Kenobi.
No, not schooled. Obi-Wan only won for the same reason one armed, unarmed Anakin beat Sidious. That means Anakin's stronger, right? No, Maul was beating Obi-Wan's ass for 99% of the duel, remely made the fatal mistake of letting his guard down for the last 1%.
Well... nah.
LOL, no way, dude, most people said Qui-Gon would beat AOTC Obi-Wan in the Qui-Gon vs. AOTC Obi-Wan thread and AOTC Obi-Wan's stronger than TPM Qui-Gon. Seriously, just because Obi-Wan's faster doesn't mean he'll win. And who's defense did Maul break more times, Obi-Wan's or Qui-Gon's? Exactly. Obi has better defnese my ass.
Registered: Feb 2005
Location: Hiding from zombies
Actually, Maul put Qui Gon on the defensive with ONE MOVE. Obi-Wan didn't even give ground despite having Maul counterattack.
And yes, Boba Fett being the deadliest man in the galaxy is hyperbole. So is the idea of TPM Qui-Gon Jinn being as good as Mace Windu. No proof either way. And it's NOT canon, since the novelisation is an author's interpretation of movie events.
And really, if it's so hard for you to believe that Depa can beat your beloved Maul perhaps you should go argue your point to people who buy into your arguments. I'm not one of them.
1) So what? He only broke Jinn's defenses twice and he broke Obi-Wan's four times.
2) Jango you mean, not Boba. Janus, EU isn't cannon. To bad we're in the EU section and therefor EU counts.
3) If you don't like my arguements then why are you talking to me? All you ever tell me is you don't like my arguements. I get it. Tough.
Registered: Sep 2005
Location: Picking up some power converters.
Point for Darth Sith, that actually surprises me, no offense, I mean it as a complement. Wait, what point does he have again? This is the EU section? Since when?
__________________
Last edited by reborn_213 on Nov 10th, 2005 at 10:18 PM
Let's see, Depa mastered Maul's incomplete form, had such potential that she was the youngest ever female jedi to be put on the council, was able to challenge Mace and put up a very strong fight and Mace mentions several times in Shatterpoint that she is the deadliest saber dueler in the whole order with the exception of himself and Yoda.
Nov 8th, 2005 02:44 AM
http://darthglentract.tripod.com/index.html Go Jawa's!!
