KMC Forums - WWH vs. Thor (resurrected)

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Horrificus
Well, I wasn't really taking a stand on either side yet. But, I was pointing out how events are being viewed and used.

I think he was trying to bring back the prof. But, I don't think that should be used as ammo to explain poor strategy or ineffective combat technique.

I think that Hulk threads usually suck because intent and context are CONSTANTLY used to override on-panel depiction.

And, my point is, that it is actually the fault of the writers, not the forum members. We all use the materials we are able to dig up. But, I think it fogs the vision when EVERY poor showing or lack of feats can be explained away with, "Hulk was not trying", or people try to make it seem as if Hulk is a good guy and he is taking it easy on another character any time he doesn't perform a decisive victory.

Thor tricked the Hulk with that ruse. And, it was easily done.

How can the Hulk even BE low-balled anymore? At this point, there really isn't anymore impossible things for the character to do.

I am just choosing to stick to what I see in the book, instead of coming up with reasons why this didn't happen, or that did happen.

If you were trying really hard to stick to the book, you would also attempt equally as hard to sternly acknowledge the Hulk's (Banner's) powerset in the days that WW Hulk was written. You would understand that the Hulk has more gears than any proprietary strong guy out there. This includes the Doomsday's, and any other brick character out there, and yes this includes the Mangog in the amount of weight that they can potentially shift.

It's just how he was written. There are many that will continue to challenge what has been written, and they will continue to miss the point. The Hulk has always been written to have infinite strength potential. What you see when he gets his butt kicked really happened, but in another instance, one that he just goes full teeter, due completely to situational conditions (someplace with no life worth saving) VS billions of innocents... you see where I'm going with this? This is Banner not Lobo (who happens to be chaotically evil). We are forced to keep it in character.

Do I believe that Thor can beat the Hulk? Of course he can, let's not be silly. I feel the same way about Thor taking Betty's place in the Dark Dimension, but not having been touched by the waters of the Wishing Well. Not being able to see the Hulk defeating Thor, or any of Thor's elite peers would be equally silly in my opinion.

The Hulk is a hero. He would fight against a universal mass murderer than join in on the killing. He has had bad times but those were due to loss of intellect.

Thor tricked Nul. Nul is not Banner, how can you even be sure that Nul was able to tap into the bodies dynamic strength potential with the same efficiency that Banner had developed during his stay on Sakaar?

You see man, you obviously have knowledge and see certain things with clarity, this can't be denied, but you've left out things or may not have seen certain factual angles. That type of thing won't work, and often is the cause of people perceiving a low ball.

Sleepy time later.