The Hulks are all different characters, as well. Different mindsets. Same powersets, but of course, we argue characters here, not powersets, so moot, right??
DCnU and DCU Z have the same powersets. They did what they did (main part here) under their OWN power. They both derive their powers from being Homo Magi. No amps.
If I see a thread specifying 'Doc Green vs XYZ', I would use feats and showings that Doc Green has exhibited. The thread does not say 'Hulk', the OP has gone through the trouble of specifying it is Doc Green. So Doc Green it is.
Otherwise, I might as well say that WBH is in all Hulk threads.
Lol...we are not talking about Death seed or Void here, we are talking about SENTRY. At one moment he can have a child like mind and even during these states, he is still extremely powerful and at and other time he can be as confident as day. Do we separate his showings based off this since his powers does thrive off of his mental state?
Lol...just because Hulk suffers from a personality disorder doesn't mean his fts doesn't belong to him. That's just part of the character. What we do know is, Banner is still in control in ALL of the Hulks.
Uuummmm, Doomsday power has been stated on panel to be linked to his anger. Those Doomsday's you named are not Doomsday's, they are replicas. I'm talking about Doomsday.
What is it that you too are arguing about to do with Sentry? Separating his feats and stuff? I'm in College so I can't really read through the argument that much.
My point was that if one goes to the trouble of naming a Sentry version, you get to use the feats as exhibited by that Sentry. If, however, you just use 'Sentry', and when people ask, you just reply with 'Sentry', then all feats are admissible.
Also, that carver is a poo head, but there has been no dissent on that.
It boils down to if someone takes the trouble to specify a specific incarnation (Savage/Doc Green etc) then we use that version, and that version only. Like Classic Kingpin, Classic Ion, Classic Parallax, Classic Juggernaut etc.
I don't use Kyle's Ion feats when talking about Sodom Yat when he was fighting SBP, for example. Even though the Ion entity is the same, and there wasn't any official depowering (that I know of).
Every attack failed because Lobo could take what ever pain she could dish out. Because she wasnt prepared to kill he could just keep coming. Hulk is every bit as capable of taking everything and just keep coming.
Hulk is not even halfway as fast as Spider-man. If you go by highest feats then Spidey has him dusted and if you go by entire history and averages then Spidey has him vastly dusted.
Kyle and Sodom Yat are two different people. Hulk is the same being, can't compare the two. The Ion is the same but it's being used by different peeps. Now if Ion Kyle while calmed destroyed a planet with ease, I would separate his fts because he is pissed off and destroyed a planet twice the size. It's the same person, same character that did it and it's within his ability. Everything ft that Hulk has done is within his ability, no matter the mindset. The onky difference is, it depends on how pissed he is which is where his power amplifies. HIS POWER AMPLIFIES. That's like me separating fts from Power Gem Champion because at one moment he is pissed off and another he is calm. Even though the gem feeds him power the more he taps into it (based off of his emotion), everything he did with the gem belongs to him. The onky difference is, Hulk is suffering from split personality.
ALL of Hulk fts belong to him. His abilities is to be dynamic. So if I AM debating Hulk, I'm using all of his material since it's the same character without any outside amp.