KMC Forums

 
  REGISTER HERE TO JOIN IN! - It's easy and it's free!
Already a member? Log-in!
 
 
Home » Star Wars » Star Wars: Literature & Expanded Universe » Star Wars Versus Forum » FoTJ Luke vs Vitiate


FoTJ Luke vs Vitiate
Started by: Darth Truculent

Forum Jump:
Post New Thread    Post A Reply
  Last Thread   Next Thread
Author
Thread
Darth Truculent
Truth is written in Blood

Registered: Nov 2008
Location: Masyaf


 

FoTJ Luke vs Vitiate

Luke encounters Vitiate and he [Vitiate] assumes that Luke is just another Jedi Master. Fight to the death and everything goes.


__________________
"Great men are forged in fire. It is the privilege of lesser men to light the flame . . . whatever the cost"

War Doctor

Old Post May 18th, 2012 09:34 PM
Click here to Send Darth Truculent a Private Message Find more posts by Darth Truculent Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
truejedi
Senior Member

Registered: Oct 2005
Location: United States


 

really?

Old Post May 19th, 2012 12:14 AM
Click here to Send truejedi a Private Message Find more posts by truejedi Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Battlemaster
Regular Member

Registered: Mar 2007
Location: Jedi Temple


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by truejedi
really?



That would, admittedly, be an interesting fight to see.

Shame that Karpyshyn castrated the True Sith Order/Species.

I'm sure if they were like the True Sith Kreia had eluded to, Ragnos-esque, that the Dark Lord of the True Sith Empire would have given Luke one hell of a run for his money.


__________________
There are no contests in the Art of Peace. A true warrior is invincible because he or she contests with nothing. Defeat means to defeat the mind of contention that we harbor within.
- Morihei Ueshiba

Old Post May 19th, 2012 12:55 AM
Click here to Send Battlemaster a Private Message Find more posts by Battlemaster Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
truejedi
Senior Member

Registered: Oct 2005
Location: United States


 

taking into account the number of times that Luke killed various incarnations of Abeloth ALONE, i don't see how vitiate can win.

Old Post May 19th, 2012 01:02 AM
Click here to Send truejedi a Private Message Find more posts by truejedi Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
ybrotes_Sargon
Restricted

Registered: May 2012
Location: United States

Account Restricted


 

He very likely wouldn't.
Vitiate's only salvation is to enthrall Luke, who managed to resist {ultimately, though not initially} compulsion from UnuThul. But without prep-time and an enemy who underestimates him, the odds of success are slim.

Once it comes down to the crossing of blades and hurling of objects, Vitiate is crushed.

Old Post May 19th, 2012 02:55 AM
Click here to Send ybrotes_Sargon a Private Message Find more posts by ybrotes_Sargon Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
S_W_LeGenD
Senior Member

Registered: Nov 2006
Location: EARTH


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by truejedi
taking into account the number of times that Luke killed various incarnations of Abeloth ALONE, i don't see how vitiate can win.

Actually this isn't the whole picture.

Luke did destroyed several bodies which Abeloth possessed but this happened due to Abeloth's reckless attempts to subdue Luke with physical means and Luke used the surroundings to damage the possessed bodies.

In addition, Abeloth also got chances to kill Luke but wasted the opportunities - blame the story arc, I guess.

Vitiate isn't much different from Abeloth in capabilities with the plus point of being not so reckless like her. Granted that he can make miscalculations too but same is true for Luke.

This fight will be challenging for Luke.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by ybrotes_Sargon
He very likely wouldn't.

Diagreed. Luke is no GOD and neither invincible.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by ybrotes_Sargon
Vitiate's only salvation is to enthrall Luke, who managed to resist {ultimately, though not initially} compulsion from UnuThul. But without prep-time and an enemy who underestimates him, the odds of success are slim.

Luke countered UnuThul's influence by using his PAST history with UnuThul against him. Luke has no history with Vitiate.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by ybrotes_Sargon Once it comes down to the crossing of blades and hurling of objects, Vitiate is crushed.

Vitiate can handle Luke with the Force. However, Luke may find a way to stab Vitiate. At the most - Vitiate's physical body will be terminated. But not Vitiate himself.

Last edited by S_W_LeGenD on May 19th, 2012 at 09:24 AM

Old Post May 19th, 2012 09:17 AM
Click here to Send S_W_LeGenD a Private Message Find more posts by S_W_LeGenD Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Arhael
Devoid of reality

Registered: Jan 2012
Location: Lost in Space


 

quote: (post)

Luke did destroyed several bodies which Abeloth possessed but this happened due to Abeloth's reckless attempts to subdue Luke with physical means and Luke used the surroundings to damage the possessed bodies.
In addition, Abeloth also got chances to kill Luke but wasted the opportunities - blame the story arc, I guess.
In which fight she tried to recklessly subdue Luke? All her attempts were before fights started. Surroundings? You mean surroundings, when Sith turned on him and he had to fight both Abeloth and Sith? First time he chased her down and killed. Second time he defeated her by displaying his superior brasilian ju-jitsu skills big grin. The only chance she got was, when he was exhausted after killing her second body.

quote:

Vitiate isn't much different from Abeloth in capabilities with the plus point of being not so reckless like her.

Taking over bodies and imprisoning souls. Controlling multiple bodies simultaneously, while in different parts of galaxy(multiple entity). Being more powerful, than either Son and Daughter, requiring their combined effort to be defeated, while The Ones are the most powerful Force entities known. Ye, isn't much different.

quote:

Diagreed. Luke is no GOD and neither invincible.
He didn't give definite answer to be disagreed. Is it that necessary to disagree on opinions that are close to neutral?
And to be honest Luke is as close to GOD as EU character could be. Potential inherited from chosen one, miraculous Force exhausting feats, lightsaber badass, good personality and high morals. There is simply no room for improvement.

quote:
Luke has no history with Vitiate.
Neither did Abeloth.


quote:
Vitiate can handle Luke with the Force. However, Luke may find a way to stab Vitiate.

Surprisingly you are right. Jedi don't overpower but strike down foes with lightsaber. I am, also, of opinion that Vitiate can handle Luke with the Force but not for long.

quote:
At the most - Vitiate's physical body will be terminated. But not Vitiate himself.
Why you even bring the topic about spirits and avatars? It would be counted as loss anyway.
Also, with loss of original body Vitiate will suck as he will never find new body as strong as his original and will need to consume another planet, which will be unlikely with weaker body.

Old Post May 21st, 2012 02:24 AM
Click here to Send Arhael a Private Message Find more posts by Arhael Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
axel_jovan
Looking around.

Registered: May 2010
Location: Eastern Europe


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
And to be honest Luke is as close to GOD as EU character could be. Potential inherited from chosen one, miraculous Force exhausting feats, lightsaber badass, good personality and high morals. There is simply no room for improvement.



Luke FTW


__________________
Theory is like a box of tools. It must be useful. It must function. And not for itself.

Last edited by axel_jovan on May 22nd, 2012 at 11:25 AM

Old Post May 22nd, 2012 11:22 AM
Click here to Send axel_jovan a Private Message Find more posts by axel_jovan Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
ybrotes_Sargon
Restricted

Registered: May 2012
Location: United States

Account Restricted


 

There's definitely room for improvement: Abeloth and arguably the Ones/Anchorites/Force Wielders are more powerful.

Old Post May 22nd, 2012 09:53 PM
Click here to Send ybrotes_Sargon a Private Message Find more posts by ybrotes_Sargon Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Arhael
Devoid of reality

Registered: Jan 2012
Location: Lost in Space


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by ybrotes_Sargon
There's definitely room for improvement: Abeloth and arguably the Ones/Anchorites/Force Wielders are more powerful.

But would he still be a Jedi after that? Power corrupts. He could have become much more powerful as Sith but power wouldn't grant him as much victories as lightside did.

Old Post May 22nd, 2012 10:09 PM
Click here to Send Arhael a Private Message Find more posts by Arhael Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
ybrotes_Sargon
Restricted

Registered: May 2012
Location: United States

Account Restricted


 

Given that Anakin's potential surpasses all the above, I'm sure Luke could become stronger in the Force without surrendering his allegiance to the Jedi.

Old Post May 22nd, 2012 10:21 PM
Click here to Send ybrotes_Sargon a Private Message Find more posts by ybrotes_Sargon Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Arhael
Devoid of reality

Registered: Jan 2012
Location: Lost in Space


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by ybrotes_Sargon
Given that Anakin's potential surpasses all the above, I'm sure Luke could become stronger in the Force without surrendering his allegiance to the Jedi.

In Fate of The Jedi series many times he ended up being Force exhausted and continued fighting and using the Force even after that at expense of his cells burning out, which implies that he tested his limits in a way Marek did. In last book he got electrocuted by Abeloth touching him right into chest for quite long time and he not only survived it but had enough strength to Force pull three Sith into a pit. God, there must be some immense power to survive lightning of supposedly the most powerful Force being.
Really the only way to gain even greater power would be to become Sith. Alternatively, he could bath in Pool of Knowledge or/and drink from Font of Power, which would make him as powerful as Abeloth but both sources are darkside nexuses, they corrupt. It is unclear, if he would retain his sanity and as we know insane person cannot think adequately. For example, Abeloth at beginning wasn't bad, there was mutual love and caring between her and the Ones.

Old Post May 22nd, 2012 11:13 PM
Click here to Send Arhael a Private Message Find more posts by Arhael Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
S_W_LeGenD
Senior Member

Registered: Nov 2006
Location: EARTH


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
In which fight she tried to recklessly subdue Luke? All her attempts were before fights started. Surroundings? You mean surroundings, when Sith turned on him and he had to fight both Abeloth and Sith? First time he chased her down and killed. Second time he defeated her by displaying his superior brasilian ju-jitsu skills big grin. The only chance she got was, when he was exhausted after killing her second body.

Here is an example of reckless attempt by Abeloth to subdue Luke:

Luke raised his lightsaber and grasped the Sith in the Force, intending to bring him tumbling into an ignited blade … then felt something catch him across the ankles. He had no time to be astonished, barely even the nanosecond required to realize Abeloth had survived her fall into the cleft. He merely felt his feet shoot away and found himself dropping face-first.

Luke tucked his chin and managed to flip to his back before he hit the stone floor. Abeloth was on top of him, her flesh blistered and smoking, her remaining leg entwining both of his, her remaining arm wrapped around the back of his neck. She drove the still-sizzling stump of her amputated arm into his throat, catching him square in the voice box and pressing hard. The cartilage began to give. He pushed back with the Force, reinforcing his larynx and trying to throw her off.

It was no good. Abeloth had a dozen times the Force strength Luke had, and he could do no more than keep her from crushing his throat. He tried to bring his knee up and found his legs incapable of moving. She straightened her leg, forcing his knee to bend against the joint, and something gave with a muted pop. He slammed a Force-enhanced knuckle strike into her side and heard three ribs snap … and remained entangled. She dug her nails into the root of his ear, then twisted, and his head erupted in pain. He slipped his deactivated lightsaber between their bodies and jammed the blade emitter against her stomach. He thumbed the activation slide and saw the blade shoot out the other side.

Still Abeloth held on, clinging to him like a self-tightening cargo cable. It seemed impossible to shake her, and Luke knew that he had to. To fail was to die, and take Ben with him. He reached out with the Force, grabbing for anything that might help him, anything to give him a second or a centimeter to counterattack.

Half a dozen loose cushions rose from the seating tiers and bounced harmlessly past. He continued to reach, felt something heavy and liquid rising from the stage floor, and a glob of molten heat arced onto them, splashing across Abeloth’s back and spattering off the floor, driving tiny pinpricks of anguish into Luke’s arm and face where it hit him.

A hundred-voiced wail erupted from Abeloth's mouth, shrill and loud and inhuman. Plumes of greasy smoke shot from her back, and the smell of charred flesh grew sickening in the air. The heat of the magma burned through Abeloth’s body to sear him, and he heard organs sizzling inside her chest. Any normal being would have been dead by now. But Abeloth seemed to live in the Force as much as she did in a physical body, and now she was using the Force to animate a body that should have been in its death throes.

Finally, the pressure on Luke's throat eased - not much, but enough to draw breath. It made him hope he might survive … at least fight a few moments more. He continued to reach with the Force, now going higher toward the ceiling vault, and caught hold of one of the long crossbeams that held the roof in place.

Luke pulled, trying to open a little space so he could gain his feet and fight, and they both began to rise. Abeloth pulled in the opposite direction, and they dropped back to the floor. Luke opened himself more fully to the Force, using his love for Ben and
his lost wife and the entire Jedi Order to draw it into him. The foul miasma of dark side energy, still swirling into Abeloth, seeped into him, filling him with greasy nausea. But the light side rushed in, flowing in from all sides, pouring through him like fire. A golden glow began to rise from his skin—cells literally bursting with the power of the Force—and Luke felt them both start upward again. Abeloth countered, hissing in anger, and they hovered a hand span above the floor.

A tremendous crack echoed down from the vaulted ceiling. They dropped again, hitting so hard that Luke's breath left in a groan. Abeloth slammed down atop him, her single leg still wrapped around his, the stump of her arm driving harder into his throat. Something crunched in his larynx. His breath came in shallow, wheezy gasps, and the crushing hand of panic began to clench at his heart.

Then a two-meter length of beam came plummeting out of the darkness and caught Abeloth across the back. The impact compressed his chest until he thought it would split. Then her leg went slack, her stump slipped from Luke's throat, and she fell motionless, her face pressed against his, cheek-to-cheek.

Luke planted his feet flat on the floor and bridged, trying to throw her off. The effort rolled waves of agony up his rib cage, and Abeloth's leg and hips slid to one side, limp and loose. But the rest of her remained on top of him, pinned in place by the heavy beam. Guessing that her spine had been crushed, he pressed his lightsaber’s blade emitter against her flank.
(Source: Vortex)

The Red highlighted portions indicate Abeloth's actions to subdue Luke. Clearly a reckless strategy.

And the Blue highlighted portions indicate the use of surroundings by Luke to destroy the body possessed by Abeloth. This was the body of Akannah.

And here is an example of Abeloth wasting an opportunity to kill Luke after the aforementioned event:

WHEN LUKE AWAKENED, HE WAS STILL UPRIGHT, STILL WHEEZING, AND still locked in Abeloth's grasp. Taalon stood a couple of meters away, on the adjacent side of the sunken stage. At his feet lay Ben, caught in a crackling net of Force energy and writhing in pain. Behind him stood Vestara, looking exhausted, battered, and—to Luke’s surprise—more than a little frightened and sad. Even Gavar Khai had been brought to the edge of the pit, though he remained unconscious and moaning in his Fallanassi-induced nightmares.

"You are weak because you have not been feeding," Abeloth was saying to Taalon. "Mortals need to feed, do they not?"

"Of course." There was impatience in Taalon's reply, but even more, there was fear. "But I haven’t been able to keep food down since I fell into the Pool of Knowledge. Its water must have been poisonous."

"And your healers cannot find the toxin?"

Taalon shook his head. "They've run every test known to us."

As they spoke, Luke's eyes were sweeping the area, searching for some way to escape that did not involve using the Force to spray them all with magma. But he was also listening, because if he and Ben survived—and he was determined they would—anything Abeloth told Taalon about what he was becoming might be a clue to destroying her.

When Abeloth did not reply, Taalon continued, "They've found nothing."

"Why do you think that is?" Abeloth asked. "You have bathed in the Pool of Knowledge, my child. Is it that you remain truly ignorant of the answer?

Or that you are afraid to know it?"

Taalon"s brow furrowed, and a look of comprehension and horror slowly came to his eyes. "I … I …" He looked over at Abeloth, his lavender face now so pale it was almost alabaster, then asked, "How?"

The tentacle around Luke's throat tightened, and his vision began to narrow again.

"First, your promise," Abeloth said. "Luke betrayed us, and for that, he must pay."

"As you wish," Taalon said.

The High Lord glanced down at Ben, still writhing at his feet. The Force net began to contract, and Ben's eyes widened in surprise. For a moment, he seemed more confused by what was happening than alarmed by it. Then his flesh began to bulge between strands, and his surprise changed to fear as it dawned on him that the net was just going to keep contracting, that the thin lines of energy would soon start cutting into his flesh and
slowly … painfully … chop him into tiny squares of meat and bone.
Luke could not bear the thought of Ben dying such a horrid and anguished death, but he knew he had very little chance of preventing it. The instant he tried to call on the Force, Abeloth would tighten her tentacle again, and he would drop into darkness. The cold tide of despair began to rise inside him, threatening to engulf him, and he felt a shudder of delight ripple through Abeloth's tentacles. She was feeding on his fear, just as she was feeding on the fear of the plague-stricken Pydyrians—using it to fuel her dark side power, to heal the terrible wounds she had suffered when Luke killed the other two bodies.
(Source: Vortex)

What happened afterwards is that Vestara and Ben helped Luke in escaping from Abeloth.

Old Post May 23rd, 2012 02:49 PM
Click here to Send S_W_LeGenD a Private Message Find more posts by S_W_LeGenD Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
S_W_LeGenD
Senior Member

Registered: Nov 2006
Location: EARTH


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Taking over bodies and imprisoning souls. Controlling multiple bodies simultaneously, while in different parts of galaxy(multiple entity).

Now do some digging about :

1. Voice of the Emperor
2. Emperor's Hand
3. Children of the Emperor
4. First son of the Emperor
5. Vitiate's hold over his Elite Guard

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Being more powerful, than either Son and Daughter, requiring their combined effort to be defeated, while The Ones are the most powerful Force entities known. Ye, isn't much different.

Abeloth is very powerful. No question about this. However, power alone does not makes you highly effective combatant. Smart decision-making is very important too. Abeloth isn't very smart. But Vitiate is.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
He didn't give definite answer to be disagreed. Is it that necessary to disagree on opinions that are close to neutral?
And to be honest Luke is as close to GOD as EU character could be. Potential inherited from chosen one, miraculous Force exhausting feats, lightsaber badass, good personality and high morals. There is simply no room for improvement.

Correction: Luke is an over-hyped gary-stu whose story is being prolonged for revenue generation and his iconic status in the mythos. If his power and skills alone are to be put to test, he would have been DEAD.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Neither did Abeloth.

Provide the details of when and how Abeloth attempts to mind-dominate Luke and how he resists her mental powers.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Surprisingly you are right. Jedi don't overpower but strike down foes with lightsaber. I am, also, of opinion that Vitiate can handle Luke with the Force but not for long.

Vitiate can handle Luke with the Force. Long-term Force based duel will not work in Luke's favor. His best chance is to find a way to stab Vitiate and fast.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Why you even bring the topic about spirits and avatars? It would be counted as loss anyway.

Intended point is that Luke's victory will be temporary, IF he wins.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Also, with loss of original body Vitiate will suck as he will never find new body as strong as his original and will need to consume another planet, which will be unlikely with weaker body.

Interestingly, Vitiate seldom uses his original body. He prefers to possess other individuals and use them. If we are assuming Vitiate with his original body in this fight - mind you, he will be very effective with his original body.

As far as the possession goes, taking over an individual with high midichlorian count can be good enough for Vitiate's plans. He can augment the power of the possessed individual with his own powers.

Last edited by S_W_LeGenD on May 23rd, 2012 at 02:56 PM

Old Post May 23rd, 2012 02:50 PM
Click here to Send S_W_LeGenD a Private Message Find more posts by S_W_LeGenD Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Arhael
Devoid of reality

Registered: Jan 2012
Location: Lost in Space


 

quote:
The Red highlighted portions indicate Abeloth's actions to subdue Luke. Clearly a reckless strategy. And the Blue highlighted portions indicate the use of surroundings by Luke to destroy the body possessed by Abeloth. This was the body of Akannah.

No, it is not reckless strategy. First off all she grabbed by legs because she couldn't stay, she didn't have one leg, remember? Second, what else could she do? He would have felt Force attack, so snicking hiding in the Force was the best option.
Then trying to break voice box and drugging nails into ear clearly qualifies as attempt to kill him by choking or breaking throat cartilage. By Luke: "To fail was to die".
So that's what kind of surroundings you meant. Doesn't it qualify as part of combat? Doesn't it show that he is capable to come out of situation, when he is at great disadvantage?
Also, before all that happened he engaged her face to face combat, when he chopped off her arm and leg without need of surroundings and pushed her into a cleft. She lost to him in direct combat and partially succeeded only by sneak up attack.

quote:
And here is an example of Abeloth wasting an opportunity to kill Luke after the aforementioned event:
It is the exact example I mentioned. Also, example of her coming with second body, when he is already Force exhausted(because of sneak attack from behind) hardly qualifies as her being able to kill him without distractions from other sources.

quote:

1. Voice of the Emperor
2. Emperor's Hand
3. Children of the Emperor
4. First son of the Emperor
5. Vitiate's hold over his Elite Guard
Vitiate could transfer his essence and his essence could be in one place only. Abeloth was fighting Jedi on Coruscant, while exactly at the same time her another essence was fighting Tahiri and Boba Fett. Multiple entity/Mind.

quote:
Abeloth is very powerful. No question about this. However, power alone does not makes you highly effective combatant. Smart decision-making is very important too. Abeloth isn't very smart. But Vitiate is.
Ahah! Vitiate effective combatant? He simply used advantage of his overwhelming power. Staying in one place giving Force pushes, illusions or Force lightning in its banal form. What cleverness is in that? In no way he was an effective combatant, he simply overpowered others. Abeloth showed her self as smart and cunning as any Sith and beyond.

quote:
Correction: Luke is an over-hyped gary-stu whose story is being prolonged for revenue generation and his iconic status in the mythos. If his power and skills alone are to be put to test, he would have been DEAD.
No less could be expected from an iconic characters. His powers and skills alone were tested countless times in situations, when he was at huge disadvantage and frankly he is still NOT DEAD. Moreover, Vitiate is an over-hyped gary-stu in his own right.

quote:
Provide the details of when and how Abeloth attempts to mind-dominate Luke and how he resists her mental powers.
She couldn't. Luke was too powerful for any one to be able to mind dominate him. On the other hand Abeloth did attempt to mind dominate Tahiri but she managed to free from her mental grasp by withdrawing from the Force. Same way Vitiate couldn't mind dominate Jedi Knight second time as he become more powerful after first encounter and Vitiate stated himself that he is immensely powerful.

quote:
Vitiate can handle Luke with the Force. Long-term Force based duel will not work in Luke's favor. His best chance is to find a way to stab Vitiate and fast.
Jedi Knight's fight with Vitiate was long-term enough before he got stabbed. There is plenty of evidence showing Luke's incredible Force defenses, surely he can do better, than Jedi Knight. Also, he fought together with Krayt against Abeloth beyond shadows, without lightsaber, getting electrocuted straight into chest, engaging her in close combat and giving final blow. Quite long term battle.

quote:
Interestingly, Vitiate seldom uses his original body. He prefers to possess other individuals and use them. If we are assuming Vitiate with his original body in this fight - mind you, he will be very effective with his original body.

As far as the possession goes, taking over an individual with high midichlorian count can be good enough for Vitiate's plans. He can augment the power of the possessed individual with his own powers.
It is not clear weather he still got his original body as dark energy inevitably consumes bodies. I actually admit that my assumption about him being weaker in other body is wrong. Abeloth was equally strong in different bodies, seems that power transfers with essence. The only difference was that body with high medichlorian count could last for her much longer.

Old Post May 23rd, 2012 07:39 PM
Click here to Send Arhael a Private Message Find more posts by Arhael Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
S_W_LeGenD
Senior Member

Registered: Nov 2006
Location: EARTH


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
No, it is not reckless strategy. First off all she grabbed by legs because she couldn't stay, she didn't have one leg, remember? Second, what else could she do? He would have felt Force attack, so snicking hiding in the Force was the best option.
Then trying to break voice box and drugging nails into ear clearly qualifies as attempt to kill him by choking or breaking throat cartilage. By Luke: "To fail was to die".

Your assessment is illogical.

Why didn't Abeloth used her Force powers to subdue Luke? Why she exerted physically on Luke? Very idiotic decision-making.

In contrast;

Vitiate bombarded Revan with his Force powers and when Revan was down, he picked up his lightsaber to strike him.

See the difference in decision-making here?

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
So that's what kind of surroundings you meant. Doesn't it qualify as part of combat? Doesn't it show that he is capable to come out of situation, when he is at great disadvantage?

You think that Vitiate cannot use surroundings to support him?

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Also, before all that happened he engaged her face to face combat, when he chopped off her arm and leg without need of surroundings and pushed her into a cleft. She lost to him in direct combat and partially succeeded only by sneak up attack.

You have misunderstood this segment as well. Abeloth's guard was down and Luke did not wasted any time. She attempted to do something physically and Luke struck her with his lightsaber.

Like it or not, Abeloth is all about raw power and manipulation but not much about effectiveness in combat situations. She clearly lacks in training and discipline of combat.

In contrast;

As soon as Revan entered the chamber of Vitiate and charged towards him, Vitiate started attacking him with his Force powers to prevent him from getting near him and use his lightsaber on him.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
It is the exact example I mentioned. Also, example of her coming with second body, when he is already Force exhausted(because of sneak attack from behind) hardly qualifies as her being able to kill him without distractions from other sources.

My point is about decision making. She could have killed Luke at that moment when he was vulnerable. She did not. Therefore.......

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Vitiate could transfer his essence and his essence could be in one place only. Abeloth was fighting Jedi on Coruscant, while exactly at the same time her another essence was fighting Tahiri and Boba Fett. Multiple entity/Mind.

Vitiate can accomplish the same with his telepathic powers. Many individuals were under his spell and they would do what Vitiate wanted them to do. Vitiate could remain in-touch with his puppets through his telepathic powers. It worked like a bond.

This can be clearly noticed in Jedi Knight story of SWTOR. After Vitiate turned the 4 Jedi in to his puppets, he used them separately for different objectives. However, he had complete control over them.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Ahah! Vitiate effective combatant? He simply used advantage of his overwhelming power. Staying in one place giving Force pushes, illusions or Force lightning in its banal form. What cleverness is in that? In no way he was an effective combatant, he simply overpowered others. Abeloth showed her self as smart and cunning as any Sith and beyond.

You got this all wrong. Abeloth has her share of talents but she lacks in discipline of combat. She wasted many bodies in fights.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
No less could be expected from an iconic characters. His powers and skills alone were tested countless times in situations, when he was at huge disadvantage and frankly he is still NOT DEAD.

This seems like fanboyism mindset. Their have been situations in which Luke would not have made through without external assistance. One such situation is being discussed in this thread already.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Moreover, Vitiate is an over-hyped gary-stu in his own right.

I seriously doubt this. He is under-rated actually. This is why so many debates about this character are taking place.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
She couldn't. Luke was too powerful for any one to be able to mind dominate him.

Again! I want evidence. In the same manner as I have provided in this thread to support my arguments.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
On the other hand Abeloth did attempt to mind dominate Tahiri but she managed to free from her mental grasp by withdrawing from the Force.

Interesting. Again! Actual canonical material will be appreciated.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Same way Vitiate couldn't mind dominate Jedi Knight second time as he become more powerful after first encounter and Vitiate stated himself that he is immensely powerful.

Can you prove your point? How do you even know that Vitiate attempted to crush the will of this Jedi Knight again?

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Jedi Knight's fight with Vitiate was long-term enough before he got stabbed.

Hint: weakened condition of Vitiate

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
There is plenty of evidence showing Luke's incredible Force defenses, surely he can do better, than Jedi Knight. Also, he fought together with Krayt against Abeloth beyond shadows, without lightsaber, getting electrocuted straight into chest, engaging her in close combat and giving final blow. Quite long term battle.

As evident from Revan's novel; in a prolonged battle - Vitiate continues to up his game with each attempt.

Vitiate started attacking Revan with his Force powers and continued to increase the intensity and effectiveness of his attacks with passage of time until he brought Revan down. Vitiate packs considerable strength, stamina, and endurance as pointed out in the novel.

Vitiate's FLS brought down Revan in few seconds. Luke might last some minutes? And Vitiate would have more up his sleeve.

Therefore, prolonged conflict will not be in favor of Luke. His best bet would be to take out Vitiate as early as possible with his lightsaber. Keeping in mind Luke's incredible speed and skills with the lightsaber, he may get the opportunity to stab Vitiate depending upon how events play out.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
It is not clear weather he still got his original body as dark energy inevitably consumes bodies.

Vitiate has kept his original body. wink

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
I actually admit that my assumption about him being weaker in other body is wrong. Abeloth was equally strong in different bodies, seems that power transfers with essence. The only difference was that body with high medichlorian count could last for her much longer.

Acceptable. Thanks.

Last edited by S_W_LeGenD on May 24th, 2012 at 10:53 AM

Old Post May 24th, 2012 10:46 AM
Click here to Send S_W_LeGenD a Private Message Find more posts by S_W_LeGenD Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Arhael
Devoid of reality

Registered: Jan 2012
Location: Lost in Space


 

quote: (post)
Your assessment is illogical.

Why didn't Abeloth used her Force powers to subdue Luke? Why she exerted physically on Luke? Very idiotic decision-making.
She did. She empowered her body. It seems she wasn't able to use Force lightning at the time, she started using it after possessing Sith body.
Also, in final battle they did engage in physical combat as well. Moreover, her final attack was, also, physical and it crippled Luke far more than Force lightning and all other attacks.

quote:
You have misunderstood this segment as well. Abeloth's guard was down and Luke did not wasted any time. She attempted to do something physically and Luke struck her with his lightsaber.
Attacking physically was more convenient. Should I mention UnuThul's Force push to remind you of Luke's Force defenses? On the other hand, when she tried to take over Tahiri's body, she easily summoned her into her grasp. But in terms of Luke, post DE we never see him overwhelmed by TK or Force choke no matter how powerful enemy was.

quote:
Like it or not, Abeloth is all about raw power and manipulation but not much about effectiveness in combat situations. She clearly lacks in training and discipline of combat.
You got this all wrong. Abeloth has her share of talents but she lacks in discipline of combat. She wasted many bodies in fights.

Vitiate stayed like a dummy occasionally throwing lightning bolts, what is intelligent in that? He had no discipline, nor training, he relied on his power and only. Exile could have killed him, should she have thrown lightsaber into him instead. Abeloth on the other hand fought multiple Sith quite effectively. In turn Luke, also, fought against Abeloth and Sith simultaneously.

Abeloth indeed wasted many bodies. However, in final book she was holding back only on Tahiri to possess her body, Saba for instance killed her in all out fight.

quote:
My point is about decision making. She could have killed Luke at that moment when he was vulnerable. She did not. Therefore.......
As you said we need to consider circumstances and she was given that chance because of them on first place.

quote:
Vitiate can accomplish the same with his telepathic powers. Many individuals were under his spell and they would do what Vitiate wanted them to do. Vitiate could remain in-touch with his puppets through his telepathic powers. It worked like a bond.

So did Abeloth. But you still don't get it. Abeloth herself was in multiple places at ones doing different things simultaneously. While Jedi on Coruscant fought Sith Abeloth, Tahiri and Boba Fett fought another one in different part of galaxy and killing one affected another. In final Saba fought one Abeloth on Coruscant, Ben and Vestara another next to Font of Power and Luke with Krayt - third one beyond shadows, all three events in parallel.

quote:
This seems like fanboyism mindset. Their have been situations in which Luke would not have made through without external assistance. One such situation is being discussed in this thread already.
He was winning and loosing depending on circumstances. He did mistakes and learned from them like in DE. However, in FoTH he was handling multiple Sith even, when he was Force exhausted. He has way to many feats. It's not my fault that authors made Mary Sue out of him doing miracles no one else did.

quote:
Again! I want evidence. In the same manner as I have provided in this thread to support my arguments.

Interesting. Again! Actual canonical material will be appreciated.

"Tahiri had no doubt it was Abeloth. It was a seething orb of darkness larger than any she had felt before, as hot in the Force as a fusion core, and it was reaching into her even as she reached for it.
Tahiri tried to shut down quickly, withdrawing for the Force and making her presence small, but it was not easily done. The thing had already started to sink its tentacles into her, and she could feel them writhing about inside, struggling to keep hold, until she finally closed herself off entirely. "

quote:
Can you prove your point? How do you even know that Vitiate attempted to crush the will of this Jedi Knight again?
Why not? There was plenty of time, while he fought illusions. If he could mind dominate Jedi Knight, why not just do it instead of unleashing all sorts of other powers?

quote:
Hint: weakened condition of Vitiate
Final boss. Most powerful being in the center of darkside nexus. There is no way he would be weakened. This is baseless assumption you desperately trying to hold on to describing it as "rumors". Jedi Knight was immensely powerful and example of Jedi truly dedicated to lightside unlike Revan. This inner strength and clarity in mind helped him overcome Vitiate's outclassing powers.

quote:
Vitiate's FLS brought down Revan in few seconds. Luke might last some minutes? And Vitiate would have more up his sleeve.

Therefore, prolonged conflict will not be in favor of Luke. His best bet would be to take out Vitiate as early as possible with his lightsaber. Keeping in mind Luke's incredible speed and skills with the lightsaber, he may get the opportunity to stab Vitiate depending upon how events play out.
Luke deflects lightning with lightsaber on first place and he does it well. Even if some bolts get through, it's not a big deal. Abeloth electrocuted Luke far longer than Revan pressing her hand right into his chest. Yet, after that he was still combat effective and handled three Sith with one Force wave. In final battle without lightsaber she was electrocuting him as well, yet, he survived and it got to close combat.

Old Post May 24th, 2012 02:37 PM
Click here to Send Arhael a Private Message Find more posts by Arhael Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
S_W_LeGenD
Senior Member

Registered: Nov 2006
Location: EARTH


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
She did. She empowered her body. It seems she wasn't able to use Force lightning at the time, she started using it after possessing Sith body.

She did not used Force powers on Luke in this particular duel. Bad decision.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Also, in final battle they did engage in physical combat as well. Moreover, her final attack was, also, physical and it crippled Luke far more than Force lightning and all other attacks.

How potent is her Force Lightning?

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Attacking physically was more convenient.

No, it wasn't. It was a reckless assault.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Should I mention UnuThul's Force push to remind you of Luke's Force defenses? On the other hand, when she tried to take over Tahiri's body, she easily summoned her into her grasp. But in terms of Luke, post DE we never see him overwhelmed by TK or Force choke no matter how powerful enemy was.

Luke certainly can put up formidable defence against TK based attacks. However, Abeloth was more powerful then him, so what was the issue?

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Vitiate stayed like a dummy occasionally throwing lightning bolts, what is intelligent in that? He had no discipline, nor training, he relied on his power and only.

This is a very short-sighted assessment of the duel.

Vitiate prevented Revan from reaching to him. This was the decision that Vitiate made and upheld during the duel.

This is how the events unfolded:

01. Revan charged
02. Vitiate Force pushed Revan and stopped his advance
03. Revan stood up and charged again
04. Vitiate attempted to crush Revan's will
05. Revan responded with a blast of power which send Vitiate packing in backwards direction
06. Revan charged again
07. Vitiate unleashed Force Lightning on Revan and stopped his advance
08. Revan defended himself and charged again
09. Vitiate unleashed more powerful Force Lightning on Revan and stopped his advance
10. Revan deflected the Force Lightning back at Vitiate
11. Vitiate got taste of his own medicine and was further pushed backward
12. Revan charged again
13. Vitiate unleashed FLS
14. Revan attempted to defend himself but got badly wounded
15. T3 stepped in to save Revan and engulfed Vitiate with flames
16. Vitiate defended himself and destroyed T3 with a blast of power in response
17. Revan was healing his wounds with the Force but could not respond
18. Vitiate picked up Revan's lightsaber to strike him with it
19. Meetra saved Revan

Now explain to me that how Vitiate lacks in combat discipline. Also on what basis have you assumed that Vitiate is not trained in the ways of the Force?

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Exile could have killed him, should she have thrown lightsaber into him instead.

Yes, I know this. Vitiate's attention was on Revan and Meetra took advantage.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Abeloth on the other hand fought multiple Sith quite effectively. In turn Luke, also, fought against Abeloth and Sith simultaneously.

Vitiate have comparable feats. The manner in which he dealt with the Jedi Strike Team is flawless and epic.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Abeloth indeed wasted many bodies. However, in final book she was holding back only on Tahiri to possess her body, Saba for instance killed her in all out fight.

And Vitiate never wasted bodies like her.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
As you said we need to consider circumstances and she was given that chance because of them on first place.

She fights recklessely and also makes foolish decisions. Double plus for her.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
So did Abeloth. But you still don't get it. Abeloth herself was in multiple places at ones doing different things simultaneously. While Jedi on Coruscant fought Sith Abeloth, Tahiri and Boba Fett fought another one in different part of galaxy and killing one affected another. In final Saba fought one Abeloth on Coruscant, Ben and Vestara another next to Font of Power and Luke with Krayt - third one beyond shadows, all three events in parallel.

This example also reveals that Abeloth committed another blunder (bad decision making). She wasted so many bodies that it ultimately became her undoing.

I have pointed out to you that Abeloth lacks in combat discipline. She possessed lot of power but could not utilize it effectively due to bad decisions she made. This is why her opponents succeeded against her.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
He was winning and loosing depending on circumstances.

This is what dramatic conflict is all about.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
He did mistakes and learned from them like in DE. However, in FoTH he was handling multiple Sith even, when he was Force exhausted. He has way to many feats. It's not my fault that authors made Mary Sue out of him doing miracles no one else did.

Vitiate managed to collapse a gigantic building after getting struck down. He performed this feat in a bad condition. Now imagine what he could do in good condition.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
"Tahiri had no doubt it was Abeloth. It was a seething orb of darkness larger than any she had felt before, as hot in the Force as a fusion core, and it was reaching into her even as she reached for it.
Tahiri tried to shut down quickly, withdrawing for the Force and making her presence small, but it was not easily done. The thing had already started to sink its tentacles into her, and she could feel them writhing about inside, struggling to keep hold, until she finally closed herself off entirely. "

Thanks. This is Tahiri's part. Now where is the Luke's part?

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Why not? There was plenty of time, while he fought illusions. If he could mind dominate Jedi Knight, why not just do it instead of unleashing all sorts of other powers?

Story Arc?

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Final boss. Most powerful being in the center of darkside nexus. There is no way he would be weakened. This is baseless assumption you desperately trying to hold on to describing it as "rumors". Jedi Knight was immensely powerful and example of Jedi truly dedicated to lightside unlike Revan. This inner strength and clarity in mind helped him overcome Vitiate's outclassing powers.

The claim is baseless? On what merit can you challenge this claim?

SWTOR players have made this revelation. Here is one example; http://revanantzforcesguild.com/abo...peror-defeated\

You are in no position to challenge this claim unless you have played SWTOR and completed all storylines.

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Arhael
Luke deflects lightning with lightsaber on first place and he does it well. Even if some bolts get through, it's not a big deal. Abeloth electrocuted Luke far longer than Revan pressing her hand right into his chest. Yet, after that he was still combat effective and handled three Sith with one Force wave. In final battle without lightsaber she was electrocuting him as well, yet, he survived and it got to close combat.

Lightsaber is feasible to a certain extent. FLS is too big of blast of energy to contain with a lightsaber.

And how potent is Force Lightning of Abeloth?

Vitiate has demonstrated most potent Force Lightning to date. He can melt metal with it. He knocked out an extremely proficient Tutaminis user with it in few seconds.

Last edited by S_W_LeGenD on May 24th, 2012 at 07:16 PM

Old Post May 24th, 2012 07:07 PM
Click here to Send S_W_LeGenD a Private Message Find more posts by S_W_LeGenD Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Arhael
Devoid of reality

Registered: Jan 2012
Location: Lost in Space


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
[B]She did not used Force powers on Luke in this particular duel. Bad decision.
She did use her Force powers.
"He pushed back with the Force, reinforcing his larynx and trying to throw her off. It was no good. Abeloth had a dozen times the Force strength Luke had, and he could do no more than keep her from crushing his throat." The straggle was Force based as much as physical. Whatever was her intention, your assumption of her not using her full capabilities to subdue Luke are illogical.

quote:
How potent is her Force Lightning?
As potent as her superior power. Force lightning strength directly depends on power, is it not??? It was potent enough to successfully electrocute Coran Horn, who's specific strength and unique talent is absorbing Force and energy.

quote:
No, it wasn't. It was a reckless assault.
You are entitled to your own opinion, what exactly would be more effective in that case?


quote:
Luke certainly can put up formidable defence against TK based attacks. However, Abeloth was more powerful then him, so what was the issue?
Vitiate was way more powerful, than Jedi Knight, even if we consider "fan assumption of him been weakened", so what was the issue?

quote:
Vitiate prevented Revan from reaching to him. This was the decision that Vitiate made and upheld during the duel.
This is not the decision, this is the only way to survive. There is nothing intelligent in that whatsoever. Even complete idiot will know that it is better to keep away from a guy with knife. On the other hand he made very smug and foolish decision by picking up lightsaber and approaching Revan instead of finishing him straight away, which could have cost him life.

quote:
Now explain to me that how Vitiate lacks in combat discipline. Also on what basis have you assumed that Vitiate is not trained in the ways of the Force?
There is no discipline in staying in one place relying utterly on his superior power. He never try to outsmart anyone in direct confrontation as due to his superior power is was not needed. Don't twist my statements, I never said he was not trained in the ways of the Force.

quote:
Vitiate have comparable feats. The manner in which he dealt with the Jedi Strike Team is flawless and epic.
Yes, it is. They were not powerful enough to counter him and Jedi Knight had still much to learn. And I am not denying that he had comparable feats. Also, apparently, there is a limit to maximum power that can be achieved. For that reason Abeloth started multiplying as pure Darkside power in one body couldn't get purer.

quote:
And Vitiate never wasted bodies like her.


She fights recklessly and also makes foolish decisions. Double plus for her.


This example also reveals that Abeloth committed another blunder (bad decision making). She wasted so many bodies that it ultimately became her undoing.

I have pointed out to you that Abeloth lacks in combat discipline. She possessed lot of power but could not utilize it effectively due to bad decisions she made. This is why her opponents succeeded against her.

Of course he didn't, he was hiding on Dromund Kaas in the middle of Darkside nexus the whole time and Jedi Knight happened to be the only truly powerful foe he faced apart from Revan.
While I agree that she got killed by Tahiri and Boba Fett because she wanted her body and she had twisted idea of making Son and Daughter out of Ben and Vestara. Fights with Saba and Luke and Krayt were all out with no mercy.
She does fight very effectively, which is evidenced on many occasions. In very first fight she was attacked by 4 Sith and 2 Jedi, yet, she fought them simultaneously and was teleporting around, on top of that control web was brought down on her. On her runaway she killed 3 random Sith like an inconvenient obstacle. After Luke ripped Callista out of her, over 20 Sith attacked Luke, Ben and Vestara, and another strike team attacked Abeloth and she was tearing them apart as well. It is clear that unless there is someone truly powerful against her like Luke or Saba, they go down more or less instantly.

quote:
This is what dramatic conflict is all about.
So why trying to mitigate his feats and capabilities, if it plays both ways around?

quote:
Vitiate managed to collapse a gigantic building after getting struck down. He performed this feat in a bad condition. Now imagine what he could do in good condition.
Why imagining, if he showed what he could do in good condition during the actual fight?

quote:
Thanks. This is Tahiri's part. Now where is the Luke's part?
There is no example as she couldn't. But she definitely would as it is the easiest option. There is a reason why she kept trying to trick him and using his former girlfriend's essences. It is Luke with potential of chosen one in his peak, remember? His will is unbreakable as he's already had all possible trials, she needed to expose his emotions and doubts to break his will.

quote:
Story Arc?
Hmm. You were talking so much about his intelligence and decision making earlier on, perhaps, I will now use your weapon against you. It was reckless to use Force bolts instead of Force Lightning Storm! It was reckless not to try to mind dominate him considering all the time spent for conversation and battling illusions! It was reckless to use ones again Force Lightning instead of Force Lightning Storm and on top of that walk towards him instead of keeping distance! He is so unintelligent and reckless in combat!

quote:
The claim is baseless? On what merit can you challenge this claim?

SWTOR players have made this revelation. Here is one example; http://revanantzforcesguild.com/abo...peror-defeated\

You are in no position to challenge this claim unless you have played SWTOR and completed all storylines.
On the merit that it is not canon. It is not revelation, it is naked statement of a random fan from a random website. I can find for you website with revelation that Ja Ja Binks was uber powerful and destroyed more droids, than majority of Jedi.


quote:
Lightsaber is feasible to a certain extent. FLS is too big of blast of energy to contain with a lightsaber.
That's your opinion. Which was proven wrong by Jedi Knight, Luke on several occasions, Windu and many other characters I am lazy to name.

quote:
Vitiate has demonstrated most potent Force Lightning to date. He can melt metal with it.
That's, also, your opinion, which you rightfully entitled to. What metal did he melt with it? It was Revan's skin melting and sticking to mask.
"His skin began to boil and blister, the flash of his face melting and sticking to the superheated metal of his mask".

Last edited by Arhael on May 25th, 2012 at 06:08 AM

Old Post May 25th, 2012 06:00 AM
Click here to Send Arhael a Private Message Find more posts by Arhael Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Str0ke
Restricted

Registered: Jul 2012
Location: California

Account Restricted


 

luke

Old Post Aug 3rd, 2013 04:24 PM
Click here to Send Str0ke a Private Message Find more posts by Str0ke Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
All times are UTC. The time now is 08:08 PM.
  Last Thread   Next Thread

Email this Page
Subscribe to this Thread
   Post New Thread  Post A Reply

Forum Jump:
Search by user:
 

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON

Text-only version
 

< Contact Us - KillerMovies.com - Forum Archive - Forum Rules >


© Copyright 2000-2006, KillerMovies.com. All Rights Reserved.
Forum powered by: vBulletin, copyright ©2000-2006, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.