Very difficult choice. If Anakin had not gotten hurt in Mustafar he would be the strongest Jedi/Sith ever, but people say NJO Luke is the strongest Jedi. Hmmm...I'm going for Anakin. His force power would be higher then Luke's.
Registered: May 2005
Location: Ancient Sith Temple
if anakin hadnt gotten hurt he still would of had to practice a crapload to reach his prime and I think he would die some other way because of his arrogance later on
but since in this fight his in his full potential he wins
He did bring balance to the force. He has the most potential. His Midichlorian count was a lot higher then Yoda. If he reached his full potential then he would be greater then any other Jedi/Sith including Luke, Yoda, Revan, Malak, Mace, Sidious, Dooku, and all the others.
It never intended for him to be the best jedi ever, but he had to be the powerful enough to survive if he was to bring the balance. I myself dont believe he is the strongest. Niether as ROTS Anakin nor Vader.
__________________
When the darkness comes, keep an eye on the light no matter how far away it seems.
Anakin wins, if he didn't fall into lava that is. NJO Luke Skywalker is powerful, but Anakin is the "Chosen One" and at full potential he would excel way beyond Luke.
Anakin's potential is a cap on how powerful he can become; not how powerful he is. And Anakin at full potential would defeat Luke, please don't argue against it. But it would be a fairly close amtch. Luke would put up a fight, but out of every 100 fights, Anakin would win 100.
Because that is never written in stone, only that he was to bring balance to the force, and we know he had a higher potential than yoda but we dont know if he had a higher potential than luke, he probably did but its not for certain.