Re: Re: The Top 10 Most Historically Inaccurate Movies
Chicken pox can be fatal, though it's extremely rare. I think they meant smallpox though, as that certainly is deadly and smallpox outbreaks happened several times in Rome's history.
Re: The Top 10 Most Historically Inaccurate Movies
The fact that 300 was based off of a very stylized graphic novel, and that neither the novel nor the film claimed to be historically accurate, makes this guy lose points.
There are probably dozens of films that are more inaccurate than these 10, the author's just picking them because they're known commodities that he can make lame jokes about and (almost) everyone will get them.
__________________
Last edited by Strangelove on Aug 14th, 2008 at 08:59 AM
how about space cowboys when, at the end, they blast tommy lee jones off to the moon while riding a massive nuclear warhead platform at 30,000mph and despite him having no way to land he still manages to walk away from the crash and sit against a rock on the moon and look at the earth until he dies.
Gender: Female Location: at the second star to the right
I can't believe Pocahontas and Anastasia weren't on this list. Even "The New World," which is an improvement from Disney's Pocahontas took liberties. Also, since most archeologists believe the Trojan War did take place now, would Troy apply here?
Re: The Top 10 Most Historically Inaccurate Movies
Excellent fun thread.
Just because Mammoths weren´t found in the desert doesn´t mean they weren´t used to build them, its been proven that the Pyramids were eroded by rain, tropical rain forest type rain. And they were built 10,000 years ago when there wasn´t a desert there. So daft as it may sound it could be possible. I doubt that the large variety of races which were present in the movie were around though.)
There's an anachronism in Saving Private Ryan that's forgivable, but Spielberg and his entourage still should have spotted it. The phone in the Ryan family farmhouse had a coiled cord instead of a straight one. Coiled phone-cords weren't invented until the 50's.