I don't know, but he did wade through the soldiers in the panel I posted, not the one you are referencing. I'm not going to post it again. You should look at it.
As far as you trying to determine what sort of feat it was, that's your thought, not mine. I never termed it a "feat", All I said was that he defeated him, which he did.
As far as the topic, yes. But this thread, as most threads, had a number of side arguments, one of which is that BP isn't that formidable and is simply the "flavor of the month." You did read that, correct? That's what I commented on originally. As I said, I don't think BP as much of a chance against Strange outside of a ton of one sided prep.
__________________
Last edited by Blue Area Vet on May 20th, 2015 at 02:43 PM
I'm 43 and you are a wet, dirty puppy to me. 43 is probably old to you because you because you don't know where your next meal is coming from. Now, let me demonstrate my maturity and cut your neophyte ass off. Have fun talking to the screen on the library computer you are accessing.
And I trust you read the posts where I said, multiple times, that nobody said that BP DIDN'T defeat BD - correct?
The only thing people have been saying is that due to its nature, it's not really usable - did you read that part? Style has said it, kris too, as have I.
I hope you can see the relevance my questions have. I asked if it was a magic feat, because if he used magic to defeat BD, that's a good feat, and we can use it to strengthen one's argument that he can beat Dr Strange.
If it was a skill feat, you can use it to strengthen your argument that he beats, Wolverine, say (as an example).
If it was a strength feat, you can use it to strengthen one's argument that he can beat Abomination in h2h, for example.
But if you cannot say whether it was a strength/skill/magic etc feat? Then what good is him beating BD, when even the writer/artist cannot say how he did it lol.
You are writing the same thing over and over. I've already responded to that. Now I'll ask you again, did you read where a poster said that BP was simply the flavor of the month or not because you totally ignored my question. Conversation is two way. One person doesn't answer the other persons questions while not getting any of his answered.
I shall make another post, as previously you called me into question over edits.
Yes, I saw wulee's post on him being the flavour of the month. I ignored it, for two reasons: 1, I don't think its true, and 2, wulee is not posting atm, so there's no interaction between us.
BP beating BD happened. No doubt about it.
HOW he did it, is what is being questioned, to gauge it's usefulness on KMC. That is what Style/Kris and I have said, and been saying.
Without knowing how he did it, it has very limited use in a battleboard situation.
Great. You took the long way around, but you got there. Wulee's post is what I reponded to initially and that's what drew me into the post. The battle wasn't important to me. I've since said that Strange wins twice. As far as the question of what sort of "feat" BP accomplished in defeating BD, I didn't dodge a thing, I specifically told you I don't consider it a feat of any particular category. How could I when the details of the fight was off panel? I will say that I don't think it involved magic and I think people who are equating BP with magic are off base. The Doom War upgrade was for that story. He did break his long standing rule against using magic and is probably more likely to use it as a resource against magical opponents, which BD is not. It was a victory over a much higher tier opponent. The difficulty you are having is that you are still trying to relate my post to Strange fight, and I'm telling you it has no relevance nor did I ever claim it did.
__________________
Last edited by Blue Area Vet on May 20th, 2015 at 03:50 PM
If course it does. Defeating an higher tier opponent in physical combat is always impressive and relevant. By the way, Kris has no relevance as a poster.
But then we start going round in circles - how can you be sure it was purely physical combat?
Maybe he used magic, or tech, or both - in which case, it is an impressive magic/tech/prep feat.
There's a 'Human Panther without amps vs Punisher' thread here.Can I argue that BP used pure H2H skill in defeating BD, and so, he would utterly rapestomp Punisher?
No to magic because BP is not a magic wielder. Yes to tech because he alway uses some level of tech. We don't see him armed with anything outside of his normal kit.
I did say a while back that I thought Black Panther had a 'flavour of the month' feel about him. I have followed the argument that followed, and I realise now that that was a bit of an ignorant statement. Black Panther clearly doesn't stand a chance against Strange, but 'flavour of he month'? Nah. He's been powerful for a lot longer than I gave him credit for.
KMC Community Forums
May 20th, 2015 02:21 PM
