My First Mister Reviews

My First Mister Review
by Jerry Saravia (Rating: 2.5/4)
Leelee Sobieski has an earthy, ethereal presence that makes you fall in love with her. She has narrowly shaped-eyes that can see what you are really thinking, and you feel wrong to tell her anything but the truth. Sobieski is perfectly cast in "My First...more

My First Mister Review
by JoBlo (Rating: 7/10)
PLOT: A 17-year old alienated Goth chick with piercings all over her face goes to the mall to find a job and ends up meeting a 49-year old man who takes a chance on her at his store. The man also has his own issues, like loneliness and the inability to...more

My First Mister Review
by Eugene Novikov (Rating: C-)
There's a terrific movie somewhere inside Christine Lahti's My First Mister, but it's kept hidden by the trite trappings of a Lifetime movie-of-the-week. The sometimes-clever, formulaically sappy script should please the undiscerning -- or at least...more

My First Mister Review
by Karina Montgomery
I should say right off the bat that before I saw this film, Albert Brooks was the only attraction for me to go see it - for some reason I have developed this rabid anti-Leelee Sobieski attitude which I have had trouble overcoming. My First Mister did...more

My First Mister Review
by Jonathan F. Richards
Jennifer (Leelee Sobieski) is a mess. Alienated, friendless, sullen, purpled-haired, tattooed, kohl-eyed, black-clad, pierced and be-ringed like a dime store St. Sebastian, she is half in love with death, a seventeen-year-old virgin whose sexuality...more

My First Mister Review
by David N. Butterworth (Rating: 3.5/4)
"My First Mister" may be a notable first Although it continues the disturbing Hollywood trend of an older man paired with a much younger woman (see Woody Allen's "The Curse of the Jade Scorpion" for the latest and probably most extreme example), for...more

My First Mister Review
by Pete Croatto (Rating: 3/5)
Looking back, My First Mister started to fall apart when John Goodman was first introduced as a pot-smoking, long-haired hippie remnant from The Big Lebowski. After that a terminal illness surfaces, then a character goes on a road trip, where the seeds...more

My First Mister Review
by Susan Granger (Rating: 8/10)
Susan Granger's review of "MY FIRST MISTER" (Paramount Classics) If you enjoy heartwarming, feel-good movies, this is a must see! Actress Christine Lahti turns director with this quirky, poignant tale of two people who get a second chance. 17...more

My First Mister Review
by Robin Clifford
Academy Award winner Christine Lahti makes her feature film debut with "My First Mister," a tale about a relationship that grows between two lonely people, 17-year-old Jennifer (Lee Lee Sobieski) and 49-year-old Randall (Albert Brooks). more

My First Mister Review
by Laura Clifford
When Jennifer 'call me J' (Leelee Sobieski, "Joy Ride") loses her job at a fringe goth/punk shop, the pierced and tattooed teen heads for the local mall. Amused by watching an older man decorate the window of a men's shop, J asks about his 'Help...more

My First Mister Review
by Harvey S. Karten
Reviewed by Harvey Karten Paramount Classics Director: Christine Lahti Writer: Jill Franklyn Cast: Albert Brooks, Leelee Sobieski, Mary Kaye Place, John Goodman, Michael McKean, Desmond Harrington Screened at: Broadway Screening Rm. NYC...more
My First Mister Review
by Steve Rhodes
Leelee Sobieski delivers the best performance of her career in Christine Lahti's MY FIRST MISTER. Both funny and touching, Sobieski plays Jennifer -- she prefers to be called simply J -- a character who's the complete opposite of the leader of the math...more