The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc Review

by "Berge Garabedian" (drsuess AT microtec DOT net)
November 22nd, 1999

MESSENGER: THE STORY OF JOAN OF ARC
RATING: 6 /10 --> Barely recommendable

For more reviews and movie screensavers, visit http://www.joblo.com/
Director Luc Besson decided to give the lead role of Joan of Arc to a lesser known actress named Milla Jovovich, a woman probably best known for her part in Besson's own ode to science-fiction called THE FIFTH ELEMENT. A balsy move on his part, especially when you consider the big budget of this movie, but one which we could all respect, considering the director's obvious support for unproven talent. Oops, did I say "obvious support for unproven talent"...I meant, obvious support for his wife! They were a married couple during the filming of this movie, but separated soon thereafter. Oh well...on to the review.

PLOT:
Young, religious, carefree French girl turns into a confident, focused young adult who feels the hand of God leading her into battle with the English in the early 1400s. After confronting the soon-to-be King of France with her visions from above, he allows her to fight his war and reap the rewards thereof. Soon thereafter, Joan is left to waddle with the voices inside her head whose divinity suddenly come into question.

CRITIQUE:
Stylish, overlong, uneven, ambitious battle drama features some excellent fight sequences, good performances by all involved (except Dustin Hoffman as Dustin Hoffman in a robe) and a lagging third act which essentially turns the story of a heroine fighting the battle of the good, into a psychological drama about whether or not Joan was just cooky! This film starts off slow with Besson spending too much time on Joan's revelations, while drowning us with his usual panache for the stylish shots. Unlike others, I personally didn't mind the modernization of this tale and actually started enjoying myself once Joan led her willing army into battle. I was however torn between how I should feel about Joan as Besson presents her to us as a strong-minded, confident, fighter woman while allowing his lead actress to portray her as a constantly teary-eyed, confused, schitzo with a supposed plan. I wanted to feel for her, but eventually, I just lost any compassion for her within all the confusion of her character.

Mrs. JoBlo disagreed with me and wholeheartedly enjoyed this film. She thought the character of Joan was shown in all her strengths and weaknesses, lending a stronger credibility to her persona. I did not see that. I wished that Besson would have stuck to one story line in this picture, instead of forcing us to withstand his own interpretation of what might've happened, in that, Joan might just have been a psychologically disturbed woman with a penchant for the grandiose. The film basically just ran too long for me with the last act dragging the whole show to a standstill. Were they just voices in her head? Will they allow her to confess her sins? Whatever. Seemed like another movie altogether. I think I'm being harder on this picture because I truly was enjoying its middle half with a female heroine strong enough in her will to kick any Hollywood bullcrap action star in the balls and walk away with her head up high. Jovovich also played her part very well, considering the struggles within herself that Besson's script needed her to portray. I personally would rather not have seen so much of her schitzo side, which I believed to take away from the film's momentum, and would have cut about thirty minutes from its length, but all in all, some cool battle scenes, a hip but confusing lead character, great direction and just too much esoteric psycho-babbling.

Some may like it for its battles and dislike its conscience-grinding moments, others may like its head games and dislike its fight scenes. If you're lucky, you'll like them both, but if you're not lucky, well...this movie just ain't for you.

Little Known Facts about this film and its stars:
Director Luc Besson's formative years were spent following his parents, scuba diving instructors, around the world. His early life was entirely aquatic, which explains his 1988 film LE GRAND BLEU, dedicated to the deep blue sea. Word on the street is that he wrote the draft scripts for that film and THE FIFTH ELEMENT during his days in high school. Ironically, he planned on becoming a marine biologist specializing in dolphins until a diving accident at the age of seventeen rendered him unable to dive any longer. He then got into film, and the rest as they say, is history. Milla Jovovich's middle name is Natasha. She was born in Kiev, Ukraine and started modeling when she was only nine years old. She is also a singer and was married and divorced at the age of eighteen to actor Shawn Andrews, her co-star in 1993's DAZED AND CONFUSED.
Actress Faye Dunaway was married to Peter Wolf, member of the J. Geils Band, from 1975 to 1979.
Co-screenwriter Andrew Birkin also plays a role in this film as Talbot.
Review Date: November 16, 1999
Director: Luc Besson
Writers: Luc Besson and Andrew Birkin
Producer: Patrice Ledoux
Actors: Milla Jovovich as Joan of Arc
John Malkovich as Charles VII
Genre: Drama
Year of Release: 1999
---------------------------------------
JoBlo's Movie Emporium
http://www.joblo.com
---------------------------------------
(c) 1999 Berge Garabedian

More on 'The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc'...


Originally posted in the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup. Copyright belongs to original author unless otherwise stated. We take no responsibilities nor do we endorse the contents of this review.