Jack Sparrow vs. Aragorn · Movie Discussion

FallingBlue Twilight of Shadow

aragorn, jack is awesome and all, but i mean..its aragorn for gods sake

CapinJacksparow Captain Jack Sparrow

Originally posted by billyboyd4ever
WHY!!! WHY CAN HE KICK ARAGORN'S ASS? WOULD SOMEONE PLEASE GFIVE ME A REASON BESIDES HIM USING HIS GUN!!!

there is no reason... they're in denile, and i ain't just talkin about a river in egypt. but seriously, the jack fans just can admit it. aragorn is a better sword fighter than jack. and they are too ashamed to say it. i'm sayin it because they will never be in a fight 🙂 just read me story a few posts back 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂

daronisgod Mesmerized & Hypnotized

Aragorn of course, I love Jack too, but Aragorn's a skilled swordsman and has spent his whole life fighting and, more importantly, staying alive.

Though I don't see why they would have a reason to fight in the first place, Aragorn wouldn't hurt Jack, what reason would he have, and for that matter Jack wouldn't hurt Aragorn.

And Aragorn is in no way arrogant, that's the dumbest thing I've ever read.

PiratePrincess Johnny's secret lover!!

I think Jack wins for me! Aragorn is kool too, but Jack's humor and craziness just does it for me!

billyboyd4ever Diamond of Long Cleeve

urhg you people!!! this sint comparing their personalities its comparing their fighting skills. somehow i dont kno if jack humor and craziness would get him out of a fight.... 😑

frootlooplucy Misunderstood Ant

lol, exactly! i wish it would but i wouldnt. i think that... Will/Legolas would jump in and stand between them and reconcile their differences thus saving the day lol. but if that didnt happen, Aragorn would win without a doubt, should he perform the incredibly improbable task of coming from Middle Earth to the Carribbean, which is incredibly improbable and therefore not likely to happen, so lets all watch PotC and LotR together in happiness.

PiratePrincess Johnny's secret lover!!

Oops, sorry! I didn't read the thread from the start. I thought it was just general Aragorn v. Jack Sparrow! In that case, i think Aragorn would win a fight!! 😄

ItsAllMerryToMe It*all*Merry*to*Me

I think Aragorn would win...it just has more logic to back it up...lol...but dont get me wrong i love both ✅

billyboyd4ever Diamond of Long Cleeve

haha yes...me too

the pheonix Junior Member

i like jack sparrow alot. but i would have to say that aragorn would win in a fight. 🙁 😐 😗 :/

frootlooplucy Misunderstood Ant

personally i can take or leave aragorn, im far more obsessed with jack, hehe. i just think in all fairness aragorn would win.

Tired Hiker El Bastardo

Aragorn, no doubt.

CandyKoRn In Orlando Blooms Pant's

toughie...

😕

I'd have to say.......
...
..
.............. ...... they both rock.. 🤘

billyboyd4ever Diamond of Long Cleeve

yes, but who would win a fight???

CandyKoRn In Orlando Blooms Pant's

Jack..

Cause I like him more, therefor he'd win...

so 😛

billyboyd4ever Diamond of Long Cleeve

right then... 😑

CandyKoRn In Orlando Blooms Pant's

🤨 🐰 🤨 🐰 🤨

i_am_not_sad Junior Member

u r all ****s

EDIT

(oh and by the way Aragorn would win ****ers!!!)

EDIT

Kes Philie

i am not sad> this is a warning! Bashing is not aloud.

i_am_not_sad Junior Member

Ok why do you edit my beautiful display of dynamic vocabulary?? Ohh I know you're worried the nerds will cry, well ok Bye for now.

Oh and by the way I wasn't bashing I was Informing.

Catch you round