Could Gandalf have been saved?

Started by pinksuezo2 pages

i dunno... their origins were mysterious, and i believe as good as the explanation gets in the books is that the 5 wizards appeared out of seemingly nowhere long ago, with the sole purpose of defeating sauron, and their leader was saruman the white.

yeh it went saruman the white (who specialised in learning about saurant, then gandalf the grey, then the brown wizard who's eagle saved gandalf from Saruman's tower [forgot the name] and also from the place where gandalf and the balrog.. dunno bout the other wizards though... neway.. about gandalf.. and why he returned.. he was sent back to complete his task right... was it to see Aragorn as king or ensure tha frodo destroyed the ring and Sauron's spirit... well after his taks his complete won't he be sent back up and stuff???? or will he just continue to live even though everything is goes right in the end??

It's Gandalf the GREY, not GRAY!

Also, as mentioned Gandalf falls straight down without holding onto the ledge in the books. From which, when I first read the books MANY years ago was devastated. Although I should have realised he can take care of himself, I did not realise this as I had not read any of the companion info such as History of Middle Earth Vol 1-3 and Silmarillion and the Hobbit.

I was quite young as well, was proud of readin LOTR when I came to read the Hobbit and realised how much more simple in terms of the use of the English Language is compared to LOTR. Anyway, enough babbling 🙂

i cant find history of middle earth here in the US...anyone know where i can get that?

orli i figure the best source would be the silamrillion..

sammi, i wont ruin it for u wit what happens wit gandalf at end of the story ehehehe

***silmarillion...stupid fingers

or just go to google.ca and type in Silmarillion summary to get the whole history

i already know what happens to gandalf at the end.. i finished reading LOTR today!

hehe

Nice idea for a thread. 💃

Gandalf could not have been saved, he wouldn't have allowed it, nothing with him happens by accident.