is the "Chosen One" not Anakin but in fact Luke

there is definitely a what if...thats why people come here...to talk smack about their fave things....it is totally open for debate.

But Luke went to face Vader again which crush the idea for a what if, what if can be used for things to happen in the future, never in the past.

A debate about what if of a thing that happened is among the most ridiculouse debated there is.

again....talking to a brick wall........forget i said anything.......obviously some people just cant say "you know, maybe they got a point".....no hard feelings

ps: remember the "what if qui gon hadnt died" thread? there was some good debate there........how do you explain that?

if you are to debate a thing that have happened there is no what if, cause it cant change the fact.

Anyways even if Luke was a factor in Vaders doings, it was Vader who had to take the final decision.

again.....explain the qui gon thread...me and ush had some awesome discussions on that one.....and vader wouldnt have made that decision if luke wasnt there.

Well the I thought the what if qui gon thread was stupid for the same reason I mentioned above. There is no answer to what if questions cause noone knows the answer

Well Luke was there and Vader didnt have to do it but he did. He was the only one who could do it. And by doing it he forefilled the prophecy of the chosen one

the very fact that we dont know the answer makes it debatable.....are you saying that everyone who responded to that thread in a positive way is full of it?

they only debated the what if for a page the rest is about fighting styles of double bladed and single bladed swords.

To answer your question about the what if, any what if questions about the past is useless cause no one is right and no one is wrong which means it is pointless to debate it cause it has no ending.

just forget it....i dont want to piss off a mod......stick to your guns, fint. cya

you dont piss me off

K people, I don't want to annoy anyone but wasnt Anakin the "Chosen One" regardless of whether he fulfilled the prophecy??
He was concieved of the midi-chlorians therefore he was the prophecy, the chosen one.
Is that way off the mark??
Sorry If Im wrong.

well the prophecy was for the chosen one to fulfill it(bringing balance to the force), so if he didnt fullfill it he wouldnt be the chosen one

So could it work that he was the Chosen One but just didn't fulfil the prophecy??
Never mind, I'm confusing myself 😛

no he had to fulfill the prophecy, cause after all that is the chosens ones task

So he WASNT the Chosen One he was just incredibly gifted??

he became the chosen one when he killed the emperor, he then fullfilled the prophecy of bringing balance to the force. Before that Anakin was just belived/hoped to be the chosen one.

Oh of course...like all that stuff Windu said in Ep2:
"...if the prophecy is true your apprentice could be the one to bring the force back into balance..."
Thanx for being so patient with me finti 👆

My pleasure Lyn

😊