Originally posted by Danistar
[b]Jeez, I just wanted to explain for some people who doesn't understand the differences between movies and books. Because a book story is the real story and you can't prefer movie story to it because it's changed.
It's naturally that new people creat threads that were before. They just are too lazy to find the old ones. For example, how many threads do we have in Harry Potter forum "What's your faveorite character?" ? Maybe 3 or 4 😄
Alright I won't reply this topic if you don't want me to do it. Actually, I'm too tired to disscus this topic. [/B]
i'm really not that lazy, i probably looked over a thread that had been started before, the one that's circulating now came after mine did.. not to offend you or anything. 😉
Originally posted by Exa
I also liked Eowyn quite a lot...
she's an interesting character, and without her the story would've been just half that good.
😱 how can you say(type)that? 😘 .didn,t your fingers burn on the key board as such foul muck was spelt out?
the story is great and eowyn has her part to play and play it well she does, but to say THAT TO REMOVE her small part in anyway reduces the story by HALF?............ NOWAY 😠
she is a sadly trapped woman in a mans world(no i am not a sexist)
she seeks release from a cage and sees arogorn as that escape .
if you look closly at her charicture she ,after being rejected by arogorn jumps into bed with the next hero that comes along.a man just recovering from a bitter wound ,sick,just lost his dad,and his kingdom
and this vamp takes advantage of him....
does this sound like a nice lady or a power hungry vixen??
😮💨
glorfindel, she didn't "jumps into bed with the next hero that comes along
it took a long time for her to trust faramir. they got together because they went through the same thing, she lost her uncle, who she loved like a father too.
both of them were trapped and wanted to prove themselves, they went out to fight despite the danger and got themselves hurt.
as for power, she don't need to cling to faramir, her brother's gonna be the king of rohan, she would have a prominent place there. and faramir was only a prince in a small place under aragorn.
Originally posted by Exa
@Glorfindel
I can type that because I think without each and every character, the story would've been just half that good - and, of course, Eowyn is one of "each and every character"s.
She didn't wed because she wanted power - she would've had much more power if she hadn't wed.
💃 how would she have had any power all she would have been was a sister to the king whom would have wed and she would have had less and less influence until she faded away like some sad bitter old croan.
by trapping faramir she gets to live as a princess in a land much more wealthy that that of rohan, and is able to have influence beonde her dreams ..
lets be honest here rohan is a little (hmmmm) rustic compared with gondor.
she,s out for what she could get.
😮💨