What's so bad about Eowyn?

Started by aniron9 pages

mah are you really a lotr fan because you seem obssesd with the fact its fiction, duh get over it ok its fiction but we are talking about it using imagination, clearly you have none

i'm w/ phoenix on this 1. Eowyn is so dissed,like, all the time! She's kool!!! 😒

Who, me? Soz, i spent all of last year's English course studying/discussing LOTR and other Tolkien stuff so i get kinda into these discussions 😛 lol. I know it's only fiction 😄 But, aniron, it was you who started this conversation 😉

um no it wasnt....
i dont really like eowyn either....i think she kinda needs to back off from aragorn, plus sometimes it seems like she's trying to impress people...i dunno but i do appreciate what she does for merry in rotk so i dont hate her either

Originally posted by aniron
yes she does no that aragorn loves arwn he tells her once and the necklace but happens but does she drop it noooooooooooooo!

I was referring to the quote above when i said that aniron started the discussion 🙂

Lol, that was a very clever-soundin sentence for me 😄

everyone who has my beliefs towards her are mainly arwen fans (am I rite)

p.s I hate it wen eowyn says "I can fight" I cant help but shout back at the film "no u cant" lol

I didn't start the conco, and I wasn't talking to ya anyway pirate princess coz u r coll, if u notice the thing says MAH at the start

spelling" conco= convo and coll=cool lol

i really dont get WHY people have a problem with the eowyn aragorn tension. I fancied my ((now)) best friend ali for about six months, and for four of those he was attached! and he like me as well, but he liked his girlfriend better, and it was a problem, but none of us disliked each other because of feelings we couldnt control!

me no likie eowyn

Originally posted by aniron
mah are you really a lotr fan because you seem obssesd with the fact its fiction, duh get over it ok its fiction but we are talking about it using imagination, clearly you have none

I am of course a LOTR fan, I think you'll find I've been one for a longer time than you as well. What I'm trying to say is it's a bit tiresome with thousand of threads about "OMG; Eowyn sucks; She's EVIL, she's the worst character cause she steals aragornn!" etc.

Eowyn is awsome!!!! shes one of my favourite charactors in the book and in the movies shes strong and can fight and she's more right for aragorn anyways shes human!!! and she is really pretty!

Originally posted by Orli'sElf7
how does she try and steal him? she kept her hands off didnt she? well..in the movies at least...shes ok in the book...but in the movies, after aragorn told her about the jewel she knew she couldnt have him.❌ she kept her hands off tho ✅ lol

then what was with that big hug she gave him at the end of TTT?
that made me so mad!!

Originally posted by aniron
everyone who has my beliefs towards her are mainly arwen fans (am I rite)

u mean the belief that she want to steal aragorn?

she didn't.
in the book - she didn't know about arwen until later.
in the movie - when she asked about the necklas aragorn told her arwen have sailed to the undying land. and i don't think she love him, but just idolise him. see the scene where she ran away from wormtongue, went out, then saw aragorn and gang came riding to edoras? i think she just saw him like her rescuer or something. then the part where she explain that she was afraid of being caged, of not being of any use? aragorn's like a way out.

in short, she kept her hands off him despite of her "crush" on him.

Originally posted by aniron
p.s I hate it wen eowyn says "I can fight" I cant help but shout back at the film "no u cant" lol

for this part if u listen to her tone, u'll see that she just wanted to help her uncle and proved herself. and she can and she will do that.

Hopefully ROTK will bring out her character alot more... Eowyn is cool (though I am still not sure about MO playing her).

she tries to steal aragorn????......could someone tell me how she tried too????....liking someone is not stealing

OH FFS people its a story and niether tolkien nor Jackson intented her to be a bad person

well, its not really stealing. she's just young and impressionable and basiclly hero-worships him. she's infatuated, but once she knows about Arwen she leaves him alone

exactly and also she gets her own guy too.......lol and its the same thing that she did.........she was admired and since she was available , she got her happiness in the end

and all u arwen lovers out there( hey i like arwen too) , eowyn's story ends up much happier that how arwen's story ended up