I hate Aragorn's actor

Cord, have you been taking anything lately, because if you are, I can understand your opinion, but this is just outrageous man.

1. Seeing as though you're just looking at Liv Tyler as a piece of meat, I refuse to show any respect to you.
2. I believe the casting for the Lord of the Rings Trilogy was excellent except for the actor who played Celeborn, but he was just a minor character.
3. Elves are gay? Gay? Out of all the terms you could've used you chose 'gay'. That really sure shows a lack of any manners at all while announcing your opinion.
4. If you were actualling watching out for the media and has seen the TT: EE you'd know where the Denethor is, but I see you've failed to do so I will just leave it as that.

I believe that Aragorn's voice is amazingly good for his role because of his title as a Dunedain Ranger.

Well put kit, i mean, wow, you dont' like Aragor, wow...that's all i can say, i loved his character, idont' think i would have liked anyone else playing Lord Aragorn....

Ok so yeah....Cord, why don't you scurry back read the books again, then we'll do some real arguing.

Originally posted by Kitoky
Ok so yeah....Cord, why don't you scurry back read the books again, then we'll do some real arguing.

I read them all enough times. But thanks for the advice 🙂 coz I intend to read then a lot of times more.

Reporting to your other post I must admit that I overreact about this thread title. I simple dislike Aragorn at FOTR. Vigoo is beter at ROTK.

1-I didn't look at Liv Tyler as a piece of meat, but the differences betwen the books abd her role as Arwen in FOTR, made me think why she did Glorfindel and Gandalf roles at FOTR.

2-The casting is fine except for Orlando Bloom who is razoable as Legolas.
Ok Viggo is forgiven for his acting at ROTK.

3-I never said Elves are gay... 😛 You are all really obssessed with something I didn't wrote. 🙂
This is the second post I explain that I only disliked the plague of blond elves, particularly at Elrond Council in FOTR.
As all of you shall know, only the Vanyar were knew by their long blond hair. It impress me negatively the aboard Peter Jackson did about elves look.

4 - When I wrote that post in September I didn´t had saw the TT EE. 🙂

Originally posted by Kitoky
Cord, have you been taking anything lately, because if you are, I can understand your opinion, but this is just outrageous man.

1. Seeing as though you're just looking at Liv Tyler as a piece of meat, I refuse to show any respect to you.
2. I believe the casting for the Lord of the Rings Trilogy was excellent except for the actor who played Celeborn, but he was just a minor character.
3. Elves are gay? Gay? Out of all the terms you could've used you chose 'gay'. That really sure shows a lack of any manners at all while announcing your opinion.
4. If you were actualling watching out for the media and has seen the TT: EE you'd know where the Denethor is, but I see you've failed to do so I will just leave it as that.

I believe that Aragorn's voice is amazingly good for his role because of his title as a Dunedain Ranger.

Quite sorry for dredging up this old thread, mes amis. I entirely agree with everything Kit said, EVERYTHING. Umm...I'm not going to even say anything about Arwen/Liv Tyler. That just...wasn't right, okay?

And not all elves are blonde. Figwit is cool, he has brown hair. 😄

Shall stop before I aimlessly ramble...

Originally posted by Corlindel
Greetings my friends!!

Poor Legolas. Why the elfs are so gay at the movie? Why are they so blond?

your very first post you said this-

Originally posted by Corlindel
2-The casting is fine except for Orlando Bloom who is razoable as Legolas.
3-This is the second post I explain that I only disliked the plague of blond elves, particularly at Elrond Council in FOTR.

Uh finally somebody agrees with that 😄 😄
I do not hate OB, but I think there couldve been better castings - not the looks I think if he had dark hair that couldve been ok, but its simply his character... the way he represents all elfinesse in the media and everything.

Yeah PJ said in an interview that all Lórien elves were blond... what a nonsense!!! Galadriel was the only blond of them 😠 maybe some had the silver hair of the Teleri, but not BLONDe!!

And I do not expect anybody to agree, but I think the elves at Elronds council were really unelvish and some rather ugly.

Originally posted by Exa
Uh finally somebody agrees with that 😄 😄
I do not hate OB, but I think there couldve been better castings - not the looks I think if he had dark hair that couldve been ok, but its simply his character... the way he represents all elfinesse in the media and everything.

Yeah PJ said in an interview that all Lórien elves were blond... what a nonsense!!! Galadriel was the only blond of them 😠 maybe some had the silver hair of the Teleri, but not BLONDe!!

And I do not expect anybody to agree, but I think the elves at Elronds council were really unelvish and some rather ugly.

Legolas for me was alright in FOTR. 'Coz it was the first time that LOTR was shown and Orlando wasn't exactly all that famous yet and no one was drooling over Legolas at that time. 🙄 So..they had made Legolas a little low-profile in FOTR, and that was perfect, IMO. In TTT and ROTK on the other hand, they gave him those ridiculous stunts and laughable lines.

Dude, was PJ serious? LOL...All Lorien Elves? Blonde? 😆 but in all fairness, not all Elves in the movies are all blonde, there are also some dark-haired ones...thankfully.

And I agree with the Elves at the council, the ones I saw are ugly. It seemed like the casting people just picked random people and gave them blonde wigs and pointy ears.

Hm... youre somehow really right with Orlando. If I think about it, there werent any of these ridiculous artistic things (except the cave-troll-one but that was ok) in FoTR... all that came after the first film... thx for making me think differently about it now 🙂

Yes he was 😄 he said that of the two most important elvish "families", the lorien ones and the rivendell ones, those of Lorien were blond and those of Rivendell dark-haired 🙄
I was also glad about the darkhaired, especially on their journey to the grey havens in RoTK...

I don't know what's the point of this thread... first you say you hate Viggo, then you don't... let's just let it die...
(and please, show more respect for him the next time)

😕🤨

Originally posted by Exa
Hm... youre somehow really right with Orlando. If I think about it, there werent any of these ridiculous artistic things (except the cave-troll-one but that was ok) in FoTR... all that came after the first film... thx for making me think differently about it now 🙂

Yes he was 😄 he said that of the two most important elvish "families", the lorien ones and the rivendell ones, those of Lorien were blond and those of Rivendell dark-haired 🙄
I was also glad about the darkhaired, especially on their journey to the grey havens in RoTK...

I still want to see a Glorfindel casted.

Still Here!?!? 😑

Glorfindel was probably the last Vanyar/Noldor blood elf in Middle-Earth. And one of the most expected scenes of a LOTR movie was stolen by that "piece of meat" 😛 Well..Just overreacting but it is a pity

sorry, but this is the wrong place to say anything bad aobut LOTR. THere are some people in here that get really mad about that kinda stuff.

I only have 3 questions:

A) What did you really find wrong with Mortesen's portrayal of Aragorn? Do you have specifics, or is it just going to be more "He's not hw I pictured him"? Honestly, none of the characters in books-turned-movies are exactly how readers picture them, but that does not make the acting bad.

B) Why do you say the elves seem gay? I honestly never got that impression. Was it that they are more calm, wise and respectful than you are accustomed to. Because, honestly, Elrond wasn't sending out real "homosexual vibes" to me, and I don't understand where your comment is coming from, unless it's from some deep-seated, unrecognized homophobia in your personality.

C) Why is it that you are able to demand respect for a person and their work and not show any in return? Tolkien may have created great works, and be respected for it, but Liv Tyler and the other actors of Lord of the Rings are all respectable and added on to Tolkien's fabulous story, allowing even more people to be happy. To then come on here and suggest that this person is only good for sexual reasons show such termendous disrespect that it makes your entire post smack of hypocracy.

D) How, if you're such a die hard LOTR fan, are you going to spell "Eowyn" wrong? Come on, now.

OK, 4 questions, I lied.