The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Started by DarkCanadian191 pages

I'm mature enough to admit that we and the rest of the H/Hr shippers were wrong in thinking that they would get together.
But your gloating, TS, will not serve you well here. NightCrawler was the only one right out of every single one of us shippers, but you don't see him bragging that he was right, do you? And so far, you're the only R/H shipper here to start bragging. Does that tell you anything?

^.^

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
I'm mature enough to admit that we and the rest of the H/Hr shippers were wrong in thinking that they would get together.
But your gloating, TS, will not serve you well here. NightCrawler was the only one right out of every single one of us shippers, but you don't see him bragging that he was right, do you? And so far, you're the only R/H shipper here to start bragging. Does that tell you anything?

It tells you that I have more self control.

Yes, gladly.

You know I am bouncing up and down here, but I wont gloat on here, so no worries everyone. Continue shipping your ship and be proud of it.

Haha......it's all about Harry now, not the ships. He likes Ginny, so we go along with that. I don't feel sulky at all.

Oh yea, so once Harry doesn't end up with Hermione, no one cares about shipping. I'm left alone in this. Come on, we can still debate on the subject though. It is always fun to debate this stuff. There is one book left, anything can happen, so lets keep fighting over ships like we have been doing. ^.^

I'm overly sulky right now....I hate being wrong, and I guess I'm not mature enough to accept being wrong; I'm horribly stubborn. But basically i felt sick to my stomach every time I came upon a shippy moment. Like I seriously wanted to throw up. To me the couples are just so wrong.... so wrong. I'm only about half way through the book, but I feel so unmotivated to Finnish it now because it makes me sick. Grrr....

KKdave, the book isn't only the shipping. You were wrong, thats ok. Its being human. You just got to get over it, and ship your shipping no matter what. There is still one book left, who knows if anyone will stay together (though I hope they do. Sorry, KKdave, but you must understand that I really do.)

I understand night, I'm not blaming you for being happy, because I know that I would have been beyond thrilled if my ship had happened. I just don't understand why JKR would do that though, the 6th book feels like it took place before book 5, as far as relationships go. I feel like she spent books 1-5 building up this amazing, powerful friendship between harry and hermione, then in 6 it's like she's thrown it away. hermione has been reduced to playing a much smaller role in the book, when in the past books her presence and importance grows. i dont understand it. its like im in the twilight zone or something. I don't understand it.

You had to follow the clues, like I had. I understood very well on what JKR did, and you have to see that too. I saw Harry and Hermione stuff too, but I knew it wouldn't happen because they bickered almost as much as Ron and Hermione. You will get over it in due time, then, we will be debating like crazy again. ^.^ Not everything works out to everyones likings. You just have to follow the clues.

Don't worry man. One book left. Still hope.

Ah dark... i need the help of a fellow H/hr shipper.... lol I think im having withdrawals

I'm a shipper likewise, but I'm still happy with Harry/G. Would've been a shitload better with Harry and Hermione but hey, one more book. And I still approve of Ginny and Harry. Harry chooses after all, not us. 😛

Withdrawals?

yeah.... maybe thats not the right word, i'm not in my right mind now. It's really hot out and i've been trying to read all day, and im angry. I wish i could be happy with what was going on, but unfortunately my personality allows me to become so fiercely convinced that I'm right that I have trouble accepting that (as of right now) im wrong. Uggg..

H/G has never really appealed to me, but it works. So I'm happy, even though I prefer D/G.

There there.

It'd be worse with TS throwing it in our faces. And hey, who dares to argue with JKR? Let's just go with the flow for the moment. And night, sure I guess. Let's take a full analysis of book six.

She'd listen to you... but not me... KKdave aren't you kind of taking this shipping thing a bit too seriously? Your not going to go hang yourself are you? I'm joking, I'm joking. Now, with one book left, lets start debating!... Of course I would suggest us finishing the book first. ^.^

Edited: I just figured out this is my 1000 post on KMC. Just marking it down so I can find which post it was. ^.^

I have maybe 50 pages left.

I won't hang myself.... lol no worries there, but I do feel a little down now... anyways, i'm half way through. once i finnish (and if, im trying to decide if it's worth it) then let the debating begin.

Finish it ✅