The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

umm that made no sense so, it was horibbly written if it's main point was 2 persuade ppl. ^^ there.

lol. my friend found this fic called irresitable poison...she said it was very very excellent and wants me 2 read it. the site is http://rhysenn.morethanart.org

my friend loves the site.

Well I read the h/hr crap and I still think it will be r/hr becuase it came right from JKR's mouth Harry and Hermione have a completely plutonic relationship.

i still say r/hr are a red herring. and so what if jkr said they'r platonic friends? she has been giving out hints that support each pairing! she wants 2 keep us guessing!

Well she doing a d**** good job of it! I will probably through whatever book it is out the window and run it over with a tractor if Hermione ends up with Harry.

i would do the same if hermione ends up with ron.

Lol what if Hermione ended up with someone like Neville (even though I kinda like Ginny/Neville but that beside the point) then what would you think?

i adore these two!!!!!
my fav couple all time apart from andi/bruce....
they are ssso cute!!!
jamesy!!!

then i would just shoot the book all 2gether

Do you want her only with Harry? If not then who else?

Originally posted by celestial_moon
it's bulgarian and we never heard much about him.

Out of the blue guess Hermy and Terry Boot (I think that's a Ravenclaw boy... I might have made it up 😬)

hope not but I search it in yahoo and i found this, I think its not about r/hr,

A Red Herring is a fallacy in which an irrelevant topic is presented in order to divert attention from the original issue. The basic idea is to "win" an argument by leading attention away from the argument and to another topic. This sort of "reasoning" has the following form:

celestial moon did u see the forum, cool isnt it,

yes thank u! ^^

Originally posted by celestial_moon
lol. my friend found this fic called irresitable poison...she said it was very very excellent and wants me 2 read it. the site is http://rhysenn.morethanart.org

my friend loves the site.

i read a little bt of it and although i'm not a big fan of d/h i liked it a lot!

I did dis pic

that thing about Buckbeak being a symbol of love is a good theory. and in the 5th bk, JKR didn't mention Victor anymore. unless she did and i didn't catch that. lol it seams most likely that Hermione and Harry belong together, but in some ways it seems that Ron would be just the same with her too. Ron and Hermione aere always fighting, and that's one sign i think that shows that Ron and Hermione would be good together also. I've heard a theory that Draco and hermione should be together, that's scarry tho because one is Slytherin and the other is Gryffindor, totall opposites. I think maybe Harry will like Luna maybe because they have SOME simillarities.

and that's why i say that jkr throws clues supporting different pairings.

i know it is hard to say, but i actually think harry will end up alone : (. i do believe though that ron and hermione might be together. He got quite titchy when he came to the Yule Ball with her, but on the other hand Hermione seems to be genuinely happy with victor. You know what would be mad? if ginny and malfoy got together ^_^. they're both trouble makers, and i think ginny is the only girl sassy enough in the story that can keep malfoy's attitude in check by using her own. lol. And celestial moon i agree about the clues thing. I mean cho and harry had a mad row at the end of the 5th book, yet at the end they smile and wave at each toher, probably signaling that they're relationship will stand as being friends. any opinions?