The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Actually, there are certain scenes in the movie that shows SO MUCH MORE HHr, so it is only FAIR that the editor added the RHr scene... Because there are (I believe) more HHr scenes than RHr (excluding the bickering) ^_^

Originally posted by megajoint
did u know....

the editor in Cos add this shot by himself in the movie-the shot is the hug in the end of the movie that all r/hr ship it by it....
it's absurd because the editor ship r/hr so he does more shots of them together than h/hr.
In additon he cut the shot that hermione and harry was in potion togther and left ron alone...the excuse was that it's looking inhuman to left him by himself...rowling gone mad about his decision but couldn't change it because she sold the rights of the movie...
so by that we learn never to count facts blindly from the movies they not keep the books script shot by shot.
Rowling said that he knew alot of things and guess alot too,but he's the closest one to the truth...now he ships r/hr is it a proof for future r/hr or JK said to him to ship other to trick us (or he thought of it on his own...)?

Oh, and I yep... I agree... I believe Hermoine may like Harry as more than a friend ^_^ But who knows. Hermoine is a girl... She's good at hiding her feelings... She's smart and tricky too... She might like Ron OR Harry OR Viktor secretly? But as for Harry... I believe Harry will NEVER see Hermoine as more than a friend... She's just, Hermoine to him. Just wanna share ^_^

Sorry bout before. Really didn't cross my mind. But I will say this, I am still with Harry/Ginny and I still don't think Ron or Hermione would go together. Besides, doesn't she like that one person, whats his name, I think Krunch or something like that. (I haven't read one of the books in a year so I forgot). Still, I say this again. We will just have to wait and find out what happens.

Harry/Ginny=Yes!

Ron/Hermione=No!

Course that's my opinion.

You mean Krum? *nods* Possible.

Originally posted by celestial_moon
ummmmmmmmmmm...let's stick with the harry and luna topic here. anyways, i have no clue y. it doesnt make sense since it was one moment that they had.

Um, did you just hear yourself? They had a MOMENT. Moments are big in Harry Potter.

The reason people suspect Harry/Luna is because at the end of OotP, Harry sees Luna trying to find all her stuff and feels so bad for her. Then he realises that she actually made him feel better, because the "pit in his stomache had lessened slightly". Plus, they have so much in common.

thanks for the thread, got 2 say the truth, actually I didnt have interest in harry potter books in last two years also the two harry potter movies but my classmate have the books and I got to watch the 2nd movie which I first thought was boring, when I borrowed the fourth book, I just read the chapter which was the Yule Ball bec I thought Harry and hermione were the partner there, And when my cousin gave me book 5, I have read it full bec. It was boring that day and I had nothing So thats the start of me being an hp fan, And also (Dan nd Emma had chemistry)

I'd find it interesting if they were "together".

Yea, Krum. Him. Anyway, when going onto the subject Harry/Luna... No. That's just wrong. 🙄 Luna and Harry horrible couple. Just imagen this, Harry and Luna out on a date at some restruant. Harry looks up from the menu as the waiter cames and asked what they will be having. Harry orders (so and so) and when it's Luna's turn to order, she speaks something strange. Turns out she was reading the menu upsidedown. It might just be me, but I think Harry would just say to the waiter, "Check please." Which I agree with Harry and Ginny. They are perfect. Never fight, and a small connection in the second book. Still not sure about Hermione and Ron. I will think on that.

Just to add one thing, did int he third book you ever see Ron and Hermione hold hands. If you did, please tell me what page. (I swear they never did. I think the movie is trying to mess with us.)

So the thing is, you'd already expected Harry and Hermoine to be together even though you had never read the books before? So you just skip to the part at the Yule Ball, assuming that Harry and Hermoine were "partners."? Let's think... Is it because of the hug scene in the 2nd movie? ...And the "chemistry" between Dan and Emma is just such a romantic turn-on that you suddenly became an HHr shipper? Looks like I was quite right about the Dan-Emma thing after all... 😛 Quite, not so... If I were you, I'd ship for Dan/Emma... LOL...

Originally posted by buffywill07
thanks for the thread, got 2 say the truth, actually I didnt have interest in harry potter books in last two years also the two harry potter movies but my classmate have the books and I got to watch the 2nd movie which I first thought was boring, when I borrowed the fourth book, I just read the chapter which was the Yule Ball bec I thought Harry and hermione were the partner there, And when my cousin gave me book 5, I have read it full bec. It was boring that day and I had nothing So thats the start of me being an hp fan, And also (Dan nd Emma had chemistry)

The movie is indeed messed up a bit... They're only trying to show the audience that there IS a chemistry between RHr, but the problem is--- they also want to show that there also COULD be a chemistry between HHr. For instance, the dementor scene with Harry and Hermoine. Hermoine was supposed to just faint, and Harry did NOT hold her in the book (as it described in details). But in the movie, he held her tight like he was protecting her...

About RHr... There wasn't any holding hands in the book, but there were scenes in which you could be almost sure they fancy each other (not sure on Hermoine's part though).

i can see what you mean shanie & i agree with you 100%

i saw the 2 movies before i read the books-- but unlike others, i didnt picture Harry Potter with Dan Radcliffe's physical appearance, and so with Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger. i guess i'm always like that, i just conditioned myself to think apart from the movie version as soon as i opened the 1st page of Sorcerer's Stone.

its true, i think that a lot of people are shipping HHr with Dan Radcliffe and Emma Watson on their minds. but if you will be objective enough to focus on the book's characters and erase the actors' physical appearances...

personally, i dont care if Dan Radcliffe & Emma Watson end up together in real life, that's OK. but if we talk about Harry, Ron and Hermione, i'll bet everything i have that it will be Ron and Hermione that will end up together-- based on all clues already present!

once again, i shipped this pair since the beginning! i dont base it off of emma and dan and i really dont think they should get 2gether. it might seem odd 4 me being an h/hr shipper but still.

most ppl arent. as 4 the whole h/hr chemistry, they are aiming the whole thing towards platonic. i dont think they would make it in2 romantic IF jkr intended r/hr 2 b 2gether (although i dont think they will b because it's 2 obvious).

it's good 2 share...and i dont know what that means still...anyways, the only thing i dont like about some r/hr shippers is that they'r positive that hermione likes ron back. i dont really know but SO FAR harry hasnt seen hermione as more than a friend...yet. mayb after the incident in DoM, he might change his views.

Yeh... I agree about the thing that happened in DoM... LOL... Hermoine seemed to be hanging on to Harry too much...

Hey, I'm not one of those RHr shippers who's positive that Hermoine likes Ron back!

In fact, I support the fact that Hermoine likes Harry ^_^ ... as I've stated in many threads before about "Hermy may like Harry as more than a friend, whilst Harry will never like her as more than a friend."

Well, we're not talking about all HHr shippers... But personally, I noticed that most DO ship them because of Dan and Emma ^_^

i wouldnt judge on that...

ok...here. i'm making a thread and testing out ur theory shanie623. i wanna c if it's true.

thats good...i have a thread up cause i wanna test ur theory out shanie623. i hope ppl reply...and b honest.

well,it all started because me/Celestial are friends who support two very different ships.Well now its decided..i want to make peace.does anyone else want to ship without being put down by another shipper.Prooved wrong is fine but theres to much hate you guys.All who come here sigh the peace treaty with your name/the couple you support,stating you will not put others down for their ships,you will understand it is their opinion.This is for Hermione ships only!!

EXAMPLE,heres mine

Lexi S
Draco/Hermione

and anything else you want to add is ok too..NO FLAMMES