The Battle

hey guys, I just had the best battle, what if Gondor fought Rohan, Rohan would have Eomer, Theoden, Elfhelm, Grimbold and Theodred, Hama, Gamling, Eothain this is before they died and on the other hand Gondor would, Boromir, Faramir, Aragorn, Beregond, Mablung, Damrod and Denethor (if he can fight) that would be the best battle i think Rohan would win casue they have better hoprse riders, wot do you think??

if Rohan attack Minas Tirith they whould have been slautherd,
if it was a big fight on an open field, I think Gondor still whould have won
they got more troops, and Aragorn

aragorn could single-handedly slay all the people of rohan haha

Originally posted by chica16
aragorn could single-handedly slay all the people of rohan haha

well he is good, but that's fairly over the top he ain't god

I think Gondor shall win in a siege or open field. Don't forget that Gondor is to much bigger and is not only Minas Tirith. Course that an on an open field battle Rohan could have more chances, but Gondor should win either. Gondor always protect Rohan and it is more powerful in notmal conditions wothout the war against Sauron. They are closest to Numenor ancestrals than Rohan.

If it was 100 years before the War of the Ring, Im sure Gondor wouldve won, but there arent so many people left who want to and are able to fight (see troops arriving in Minas Tirith before Pelennor...); Rohan is also weakened, so im not sure about the end of such a battle; i think gondor wouldve won as well.

good idea but i think gondor might win if denethor werent such a P***k

Originally posted by Lord_Andres
if Rohan attack Minas Tirith they whould have been slautherd,
if it was a big fight on an open field, I think Gondor still whould have won
they got more troops, and Aragorn

Basically even if Rohan did have all those horses and stuff, Aragorn would still open a can of whoop ass on em. Unless Rohan had Hammerhand.

yea...anyways the battle would most likely be @ minas tirith, where the gondorians kno how to fight and do it well.

Rohan would definetly win in an open field battle. The Rhohirrim would ride through the gondorians and slaughter them.

No thry whouldint, int's not that hard to win a guy on a horese if your on foot, just strike at the hores, and the kill the f***er🙂

"Gondor always protects Rohan"

SOMEONE has forgotten how Rohan came into existence...

don't know much about the early history of ME, whould you ecsplain how they came?

Gondor was being decisively defeated in a war against the Easterling Balchoth. The Eotheod- as the Riders were known then- migrated down from their lands in the north and in the nick of time came to the aid of the Gondorians and saved the entire realm. As a reward, the Gondorians gave the Eotheod the land of Caelnardhon to live in, where they settled all the way up to the time of the films. To the outside world, the land because Rohan and its inhabitants the Rohirrim, which is what the Elves always called them (meaning 'Masters of Horses'😉. To themselves, they because the Eorlingas and they called their land the Riddermark- hence Aragorn saying in the TTT film "What news from the Mark?"- he was being polite in using their own terminology.

From that point on the Rohirrim and the Gondorians had an arrangement via which they would aid each other in times of need, which they then did.

this is a hypothetical question. we know they would never fight for real. and the rohirrim would break throught the ranks of gondor..........cavalry is much more powerful than foot soldiers.

Yes if its well trained... not really the case in wr-rohan 🙂

if the footis are well traind and strong, I'd say gondor would win

The Rohirrim have a far more martial culture than the Gondorians, they would be a match man for man, especially with their great horsefighting skills which makes their power. But there just aren't enough of them! And Gondor is more sophisticated.

I think the Rohirrium are ten times better than the Gondorians but as every one has been saying their aynt enough of them. but if Gondor went to Helms Deep than they(Rohan) would win but otherwise Gondor would win

Gondor would also have won if the fight stod in Hels Deep, Gondor has Archers to they could just shot the men who stod on the top of the wall, so the foot soldiers could get inside the keep!!!