If..Tolkien was chating with us...

What should you ask him (doubt, wish, etc)? 😱

"What is the Noldorin word for cat?"

"Where did the different Nazgul come from and what were their names?"

"What was the real chronological order of the End of the World and what role did men play?"

"Why didn't you finish The New Shadow?"

"What were the names of the Fathers and Mothers of Dwarves?"

"How is it being dead?"

hmm-id say firstly thanks for writing such a great story! then id ask,would u have continued LOTR and made it longer! i thought the story could have kept going...🙂

[Tolkien actually started a story that played about one or two hundred years after the Lord of the Rings, called "The New Shadow", but soon abandoned it]

I'd also like to know what he thinks about PJs film

really?!!! i wasnt aware of the new shadow.thanks 4 that info exa.darn i wish he finished it now.i think if he saw the movies,he wouldnt like them that much

Here are some scans of the first pages:

http://www.fountain.btinternet.co.uk/tolkien/
He said he dropped it because it would've been too depressing 🙂

Oh yes 🙁

And I'd ask for the Sindarin word for "Linden tree" for a friend 🙂

wow,just went to that site u mentioned,im going to check this out some more🙂🙂🙂

yea my main question would be what hes thinks of the movies...which woulD probably have a negative answer

then i would ask how he was so inspired to write such amazing books

i would have asked...........
would u have written the saga if U HAD TV??