Sirius Black

yeah, i think she does very well under the circumstances

I don't think it'd be that much pressure. I mean, she started the books so long ago, and near the beginning only few knew about her books. And frankly, I think she's a good enough author that either way people are going to keep on reading these books until the series are over. And it's not like she just wrote the books for us or anything, she enjoys doing it, and she's writing it for the ppl who enjoy the books. And it doesn't matter for the ppl that don't.

And I'm sure that Sirius is dead, but I wish he hadn't been killed off. He just came into the books. It sucks...
Sirius, we hardly knew ye'.

OK, so what are the ways do you think that Sirius Black could come back, and if he doesn't then what are the things do you think you'd like to do or say to J K Rowling?

i want sirius back!!!!!!!
why j k rowling why!!!!!!! ❌ 😒 😠 🙁

Sirius HAS to come back!
It's the only way I'll ever be happy!!!!🙁
-or if LSU wins the super bowl, then i'll be eternally happy 🙂 -

I don't think he's dead, you didn't see him actually die, did you?

so yea... I think he'll come back.

Uh, he did die... All the characters explain that he did, and even JK Rowing stated it.

maybe she said that to throw us off
he's still alive!
maybe he is and maybe he isssssss... 😖hifty:
he was my v favorite character, if JK don't bring him back, i'ma gonna protest

sirius black DIES!!!!!!! 😮‍💨 thats happend in the last book

bye

I THINK HE DIDN'T DIE 😄.....just TRAPPED AGAIN! 😄

maybee harry will go bak in time (again) and save siruis' life just like last time! although i think it will probably ruin the story if she brings him back 🤘

The book convinced me he will never be back....
Why had he to die?
If I hadn't known that he would die, I would have been so shocked....
Because he's death came out of a sudden and it was so meaningless. There was no point for him to die. I still can't believe this though I new Sirius would die.
And I'm also perplexed that Harry used the Cruciatus curse against Bellatrixe Lestrange.

*sigh* im sad sirius is gone cuz he was my favorite 🙁
im hoping that the veil thing was just a trick, like a trap, and that sirius needs help... perhaps he will come back 😕

😍 😍 😍

i think dat sirius is dead but sumthin will happen and harry will either get him bak or be able to talk to him somehow like talk to whispers in the veil or get a picture of him or sumthin. oh yea, and another thing, how cum harry cant jus talk to da picture he has of sirius at the potters wedding? and for dat matter, how cum he cant talk to his parents?

he'll return from the dead i'll tell yeah. ain't there a black magic for that?
*looking frantically to the pages of the dark magic books*

i think i'll borrow that book from "the mummy".

Hi everyone! What do you think about Nick´s explanation of becoming a ghost in the end of 5. book? Why didn´t Sirius become one? 😕 🙁thanks

That's a very good question 🙂
Sirius is not that kind of person to be a ghost. Because being a ghost means to be neither there nor here. If you are a ghost you can't live normally as a human. You are just behind of everything that normal people do, whereas Sirius was desperate to act, to do something worthy, to help for the Order and if he became a ghost he couldn't do that. So, he won't come back as a ghost. It's better to be dead for him than to be a ghost which can't do anything worthy. I think he would go mad, if he were a ghost.....

I agree with Danistar. The reason Sirius took such large risks through book five was because he could not bear to be inactive. There is no way he'll accept the shadow of life that is all that ghosts have. Besides, I think he's inquisitive enough to want to know whats going to happen!