which movie was better

Started by BOPRecruit 162 pages
BOPRecruit 16 Hunter By Nature

fotr was a little slow, but i loved the sword fighting and nazgul action!

nazgulinthedark Super Senior Member

yeah i really liked fotr because of all the nazgul parts in it, and i liked ttt because of the great battle scenes, but the rest of ttt i just fast forwarded through.

carlstone81 Junior Member

love them both as much.... the second has
more special effects though and MORE OF super hottie Orlando sweetpie
Bloom.

Exa Senior Member

FoTR is imho a little bit one-dimensional. The deep of the book wasnt really obviously in the film.
TT had too many changes, but I like it when there are different strings of a story and a lot of things happen at the same time - but I kinda missed the Nazgul 🙁

nazgulinthedark Super Senior Member

the nazgul were the best...
orlando's o.k.
if had to have a second favorite charater - it'd be him

Hypernova Senior Member

Like I said, I am looking forward to ROTK and anticipate it being the "best one". I absolutely loved the book. Like many, I prefer FOTR slightly more than TTT. Though, I like them both!

LanceWindu Senior Member

For actual story that goes to FOTR, but for special effects and comedy and action that goes to TTT

billyboyd4ever Diamond of Long Cleeve

TTT all the way!!! i love that book +movie!!

Exa Senior Member

I think RoTK might be the best (though there are so many changes);
At least I liked the book best.

Arwenishott Rohirrim

potk will be the best by far. i agree exa. that book was the best, and that movie will be better. if i had to pick from the other two............i'd say tt for book and movie...........they just get better as they go along!!!!!!!

badkittykitty cockeyed

Originally posted by Arwenishott
potk will be the best by far. i agree exa. that book was the best, and that movie will be better. if i had to pick from the other two............i'd say tt for book and movie...........they just get better as they go along!!!!!!!
I just seen the trailer for the RotK man of man,all I can say is like the books this will be the best of the rest!!

shadowy_blue Senior Member

Yeah, I also saw the ROTK Trailer and I was literally crying while I was watching it no kidding. It will be the best but also sad because it will be the last. 🙁

badkittykitty cockeyed

Originally posted by shadowy_blue
Yeah, I also saw the ROTK Trailer and I was literally crying while I was watching it no kidding. It will be the best but also sad because it will be the last. 🙁
ahh but dont be sad they put in all the extra scenes and then release the movie in it's so perfect book like form and we can watch it over and over and then have lord of the ring day,I will be fantastic!

Fire Senior Member

nice idea BKK

Hypernova Senior Member

Yes I agree, nice one BKK 👆