"Either Must Die in the Hands of the Other". The Lost Prophecy

Started by Orli'sElf759 pages

i agree with you muse...i mean neville has his own revenge to consider doesnt he? mayb he'll kill bellatrix!!! ^_^ shes the one that tortured his parents after all...i really dont think that jk will do the final battle without someone on the good side dying...any1 have any suggestions? idk i mean...everything in harrys life has been soo dramatic so far and just him killing voldemort and everything being all happy joy again doesnt seem like something that she would write...

Quote:
i have mentioned this in other threads, but i think that harry will have to sacrifice himself in order to defeat voldemort..., i mean think about it.....voldemort transferred some of his power to harry on the night he tried to kill him....so maybe not only his power was transferred but also some of his strength, hence the reason when the curse rebounded, instead of killing voldemort ( which it shud have done considerin it was the avada kedavra!) it just reduced him to 'almost dead' which suggests that as some of his strength lies in harry, he will never die, unless harry dies...do you get me?

I think the last book well end in someone saying harry wheres your scar becuz, once harry has killed voldemort (which well happen) his srac will dissapear. I noe that sounds stupid but hear me out.....Dombledore is always going on about the connection that was forged between harry and volemort the night the curse ment to kill harry backfired. It only makes sense that when one of them dies (voldemort) the connection will be broken. And as for voldemort being immortal......i think the night he took some of harrys blood to get his body back, the beame mortal once again. I think thats why Dombledore had a look of trimph in his eyes, when harry told told him about what happened in the graveyard (see book 4) And i think the prophecy was made for harry not neville, because, will dombledore said so. "so this prophecy might not be about me", said harry. "I am afaird there is no doubt it is about you", said dombledore sadly. The book also says harry had always been a marked man. When vodemort choose to attack him (the half-blood) he marked him as an = (his scar) and i dont think harry will die, at least not in the 6th book, becuz then there would be no 7th book, unles he came back as a ghost (but that doesnt make any sense. No where in the book does it say they both have to die, just one of them, and good always bets evil, there might me many ppl who die along the way, and many hardships but in the end harry will win. Ive heard a few rumors that dementors will kill voldemort, and i dont think that makes any sense either becuz the prophcy says "eith must die at the hand of the other...." Ok well those are my thoughts, hope its not to long lol. Please write back and tell me what you think.
~stephanie

i completely get what your saying me15, and yes i think that some of harry will leave once voldemort dies, but it said "either must die at the hands of the other"...and i really dont think jk thought about this...i dont think shed kill of both of them. well we never know thats true, but ....idk mayb voldemort will just never die as long as harry's aliive. plus their wands are brothers rite? if they are forced to do battle they wont work properly, so i really dont know how all this is going to work. we'll just have to wait out for the book...anyone know when book 6 is coming out anyway?

well, i kind of get what your saying me15. and i think that your idea about the scar dissapearing is very interesting...i'd never thought of that b/f! But i definately agree w/ you Orli'sElf7, cuz if they both die, what was the point of the prophecy? (this also plays into your theory me15) It said that either must die...which basically rules out the possibility of both dying, it would make the end of the 5th book pointless...but i also don't think its gunna be a fairy tail ending....somebody important will prolly die, and there are gunna be plenty of hardships, but my gut tells me that harry will still be alive in the end....cuz ending w/ Voldy alive and harry dead seems a bit pointless and morbid.

makes sense to me

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Quote: by Orli'sElf7
.....plus their wands are brothers rite? if they are forced to do battle they wont work properly, so i really dont know how all this is going to work......
----------------------------------------------------------------------
as for there wands being brothers, i dont think that matters much, remember harry has powers the dark lord noes not (and dumbledore said his power was love) but wat if thats only one of his powers, think about it. In the 3rd book harry blows up his aunt and blast the door under the stairs open (to get his truck) in the 1st book he frees that snake, and all without a wand. This leads me to conclude that he doesn't need a wand to do magic, He can do magic with his emotions, as long as he wants something bad enough itll happen......
😄 Stephanie[B]

Originally posted by me15
as long as he wants something bad enough itll happen......
😄 Stephanie[B]

good point, i like the idea

sounds interesting..............
i agree that the prophesy is harrrys, i reckon that neville will have a more major part... like ive said earlier in this thread, he will have a new wand and stuff, but the prophesy is definately harrys...........

as to who will die, i agree that only one of them will, and personally i reckon it would be voldemort.... i mean its not a very happy ending is it? for the hero to die, and just to leave off with every1 suffering, and its a childrens book (principally) so i think that harry will win, but going back to something lianslo said about sum1 improtant probably dying, i dunno why, but i think that Dumbledore will die, i mean he's getting old, and i think that he will sacrifice himself so that harry can kill voldemort or something.............. its hard to explain, i think that it will be because of summit dumbledore does, that will result in his death, and in harry killing voldemort. 😄

Originally posted by cheeky munkey
but going back to something lianslo said about sum1 improtant probably dying, i dunno why, but i think that Dumbledore will die, i mean he's getting old, and i think that he will sacrifice himself so that harry can kill voldemort or something.............. its hard to explain, i think that it will be because of summit dumbledore does, that will result in his death, and in harry killing voldemort. 😄

I've thought of that myself...but i agree, it can't happen till the very end...otherwise harry would be screwed! So much depends on Dumbledore, including much or harry's safety...but basically what i'm saying is that i definately know where your coming from, and it would break my heart, but i can kind of see it happeneing....

😄
tho i think if he does die i will cry 🙁

Originally posted by Morningstar
Argh, too many points! 😄 So confusing!! nah, i highly doubt they both die, unless its a really strange twist.

I agree....i dont think theyll both die............becuz the prophecy says......."either must die"..........blablabla.......not they both must die. And i noe there only suppose to b 7 books but harry potter is such a popular book, i think theyll make more, maybi, about after he leaves skool..............but then again maybi not lol.........ok well im starting to confuse myself
-me15

i'm definately hoping for more books after the 7th! that would be awesome! 😄

Originally posted by me15
but then again maybi not lol.........ok well im starting to confuse myself
-me15

That happens to me a lot 😛 ✅

hehe 😛

i reckon that harry will kill volde....... the either must die thing,
that dumbledore will somehow get killed right at the end, and that there will be another book, after the 7th one, i dunno bout harrys career or summit 😄

i think that they've been such a successful series that there will be another one.... even if its just a one off 😄

hehe 😛

i reckon that harry will kill volde....... the either must die thing,
that dumbledore will somehow get killed right at the end, and that there will be another book, after the 7th one, i dunno bout harrys career or summit 😄

i think that they've been such a successful series that there will be another one.... even if its just a one off 😄

hmm....so me and cheeky have all the same ideas! so...i have to ask.....do you think sirius is coming back? (sorry....i know thats a bit off the topic....but the Sirius thread i was posting on died!)

i really don't know, caus its difficult to tel if he's really gone u know!? caus no-one reallyknows the secrets of the veil

maybe (hopefully) the next book will explain more about the veil.

yeah...i hope so too! But i've always thought he was coming back...b/c of the veil, it was all so sudden and so mysterious....that it didn't seem a proper way for a character we had only just begun to love to leave

yeah......... it sortof just happenned and then she moved on.................
but i dunno........... it will make things a bit wierd if he did come back.............

but then she did come back to the mirror he gave harry rite at the end of the book, and wat is the point in bringing it up if nothing is gonna come of it 😄
just a thought 😛