"Either Must Die in the Hands of the Other". The Lost Prophecy

Started by Lily Evans59 pages

[SIZE=3][FONT=century gothic][FONT=arial][COLOR=red] 🙄 Well I totaly agree with all of you but I personaly think that IF Harry dies then Neville will jump in and save the day. Think of it this way: Maybe Neville tries to kill voldmort and Harry saves him before something.........Oh well I guess we will have to wait. THat sucks! 🙁

i hate waiting! waiting for the third film is bad enuf!! i wonder when she'll get the 6th book out?!!! 😬

That totally sucks I am thinking about 2005 Around April or something. 😱

still too far away.....i'm desperate to know what happens!!!!

some people are talkin about snape killing voldemort...i mean, that surely can't happen, but maybe he will have something to do with it?!! 😬 i mean, he's helped harry in the past (no matter how reluctantly) but it might just happen.....i don't know...what do u think?

Umm... I think that is going to happen something on the lines of that but you know maybe Harry is going to be in trouble and Snape runs in for the save or vis versa you know? Umm great now ya got me thinking about that possiablity. 😛

lol! i think it wud be great tho if snape were to be apart of it...i mean, he's like my fav character....and i do really feel sorry for him, considerin what he's been through and so waanna see him save harry's life or summit! i think it wud be great!!

Hey, another idea:
Have you noticed the little differences between the original words of the prophecy and Dumbledore's interpretation? For example the original words don't mention the year when that one to kill Voldemort will be born. Dumbledore says it's only the year when Harry's born.
I think that could be a trick of Rowling, that we just remember Dumbledore's words and in the end...big surprise it's not Harry who has to kill Voldemort. I mean, Joanne Rowling lets us always believe the contrary of what's true.

in reply to that...i consulted the bible(in other words..OoTP!!!!!!!) and it says, i quote...."'It meant' Said Dumbledore 'that the person who has the only chance of conquering the Lord Voldemort for good was born at the end of july nearly sixteen years ago. This boy would be born to parents who had already defied voldemort three times'" (pg 741) and it was professor Trelawney that was shown the prophecy.....in other words, she had a "vision" (of sorts) nearly 16 yrs ago, that a boy wud be born as the seventh month dies, in that year....so dumbledores interpretation was not different...do u get me?

Yeah....okay,you're right...I think I'm not that good in getting important details because the German version isn't already out...had to read it in English. But it was a good idea ;-)

I am reading the Bible (OoTP) again for the millionth time just to see if i missed something or what. And the whole Harry-Neville-Snape triangle we just set up confused me evan more I mean we can guess and guess but never will now until the other part of the Bible comes out! 😠 I am so impatient!!!!

Me too, Lily! I read OotP three times and in 2 weeks it will come out in German, so it won't be the last time I read it!! I have to check if the translater did a good job ;-) Yeah, but I really hope J.K. Rowling will be a bit faster with the 6th and the 7th....don't know how I managed the 3 years of waiting for OotP!

Me too I am so obbesed with HP that i named my ID name after his mother. Odd yes I know but right now i feel like 🐰

;-)

yeah it was a great idea....mind u tho, we know that trelawney is v dodgy to believe in if u get me! in like the third book, most of the teachers said that they doubted her talent and believed it was all fluke....well wot if the prophecy was wrong? after al it was trelawney that announced it!

Umm very good point but I don't think that is what is happing because remember that She went into a trance and her prediction came true. Great another thing for me to ponder 😕

lol! sorry bout that!

LOL It is okay!!!! 😉

oooh what about this mundungus being crookshanks thing? think it's possible......

Er.. I guess but what about when they were at Nuber 12 place Crookshanks was there so was Mundungus was there too... um thanks again(lol) 🤪