Juggernaut or The Hulk?

The Hulk all the way 😛 Juggie is a lousy fighter. He depends way too much on his protective shield and his strength, but using tactics isn't his strongest point (granted, mostly he doesn't need to uses strategies, he just punches everybody away).

In an old comic, Thor fought Juggernaut and managed to bring down the protective shield that surrounds Juggernaut, and Juggernaut didn't know what was happening to him, he got thrashed so hard he didn't know where he was standing. Luckily for him his forcefield came back in time to save his ass.

OK, I exaggerate a bit, but I just want to point out that he relies way too much on his strength and his forcefield, and not on his fighting skills !! Any Hulk, the grey one, the mindless one, you name it, is a better fighter and at least as strong - ok, the grey one isn't as strong 😛

And unstoppable certainly does not mean invincible.

Juggernaut IS immune without his forcefield. thor negated most of the mystical energy that cain was recieving. hence, that made him vulnerable. but juggernaut more often than not, has NOT used his force field. the field extends to about a foot away from his body. thors hammer hulks fist wolverines claws usually all come into contact with juggernauts body and just bounce off. so your theory about using his "field" too much is wrong. hulk is the better fight (supposedly since in all thier fights they seem to do the same thing) but he could never overcome his invulnerability. no matter how strong he becomes.

All good points I think here.

OK, I have to admit I like it when a fight such as Juggernaught and Hulk can be argued with.

It's a tough call and I guess none of us can truly answer it, because we are all after all speaking from our own biases and knowledge (or lack thereof).

Hulk and Juggy are different and both deserve to call themselves equal to each other.

I used to think Hulk would win in everything. He'd beat most Marvel characters senseless, but not Juggy.

Hulk has never killed Juggy, Juggy hasn't really been stopped. So far it's still debatable

lol, yea. i agree. i wish they would come out with a book, like the death of superman. that would end this dispute once and for all. i'd buy 20 copies. well that would be a waste of money. i'd probably buy just 1.

dude I've seen a Incredible Mindless Hulk comic book when Hulk fought Juggernaut and was kicking his butt. Juggernaut got his helmet ripped off and Hulk just walked away. But we all know that If Hulk would have began punching Juggy in the cranium then that would be it. I mean if Hulk can crack onslaughts armor, he can definitly kill off Juggernaut with no helmet.

ok, you mean the comic where hulk hit juggernaut and juggernaut simply kicked him to the ground and said hulk was getting weaker, while juggernaut was getting stronger. i get what you are saying. yea. juggernaut's helmet only protects him from psionics. not physical force. his body is completely indestructable without it.

you have seen the comic, while i own it. please.

Look I'll say that Juggy and Hulk are a equal in strengths and that the fight will end in a draw. hulk has beat Juggy a few times, and Juggy has beat hulk a few times. They are balanced.

exactly my thoughts. that's why i wish though, that they would make a book about it. not the usual 2 page fights. i would really like to know who is the better half of the 2. no questions asked. wouldn't you?

Although juggernaut is arguably the more indestructible of the two, hulk is definitely stronger. Juggy will definitely give hulk a beating, since he doesn't get tired and all. But juggy's strength is just that, it remains as is while hulk's strength can increase with his anger. so eventually i think the hulk would grow mad enuf(and strong enuf) to beat juggy.

well, juggernaut's strength usually dwarfs hulks. hulk has to be sufficiently rage induced to match it. it wouldn't matter how strong hulk was, he could never physically hurt juggernaut. even if he reached a 150 billion ton strength level. even when he was upgraded to "war" he still had trouble. doesn't say much for a normal hulk. savage or not. infact i think it would be the genious versions that would have a better chance against juggernaut.

I guess who ever gets in the first blow is gonna win!

Beause if The hulk gets in the first blow, Juggy is gonna punch him back with full force and make him angrier, and so on and son, until the hulk flattens Juggy with a super-Hulk-enraged-anger-ground breaking shot.

On the other hand Juggy could get in the first blow and knock Hulk out although he's never done it. It would be a hell of a punch to knock the hulk unconcious with one blow. A matter afact I don't think anyone has ever done that. 🤨

i doubt anybody could ever put hulk down with 1 punch. let's not get rediculous. nor do i think the first punch would dictate the outcome of the fight.

but hulk has been knocked out by physical force, glad you brought this up. where juggernaut never has (before onslaught, otherwise known as true juggernaut).

Originally posted by JuggernautFan
well, juggernaut's strength usually dwarfs hulks. hulk has to be sufficiently rage induced to match it. it wouldn't matter how strong hulk was, he could never physically hurt juggernaut. even if he reached a 150 billion ton strength level. even when he was upgraded to "war" he still had trouble. doesn't say much for a normal hulk. savage or not. infact i think it would be the genious versions that would have a better chance against juggernaut.

are we on the same planet? juggernaut's strength dwarfs's the hulk? maybe his invulnerability yes but not his strength. plain physical strength though, thor and hulk are both juggy's superior.

ummm ok, considering hulk has to be rage induced to fight thing where as juggernaut simply knocks him out without a fight. considering hulk has never truely matched juggernaut strength for strength except in his upgraded for War hulk. considering thor has never won a battle except when he negated the very energy that makes cain marko the juggernaut. i already can tell you don't have the issues. so yes, until sufficiently rage induced juggernaut's strength does dwarf hulks. it has to be greater than hulks at base levels or they wouldn't even claim that it rivals hulks. hulks has to increase to match or over take juggernaut it's simple if you think about it.

you also included thor, i have no idea why. consider this. thor with the avengers, also quick silver, scarlet witch, and hercules couldn't defeat the exemplars. each of the exemplars were defeated by juggernaut. rather easily at that. the good guys out numbered the bad guys yet they still lost. but juggernaut held his own. explain that one.

infact i just went and counted. 13 avengers spiderman and all included vs. 7 exemplars. they almost doubled the exemplars in numbers and were defeated. ha ha ha.