Elrond

Started by Izz4 pages

Elrond

Isn't Hugo Weaving too old to play the role of Elrond? Elves are suppossed to remain young forever (young looking), but Hugo looks rather old (for an elf).

Well.....in the book Elrond is described as old but with an air of youth, or vice versa...Young but with an air of aged wisdom...I think Hugo meets that requirement.

A little note from the encyclopedia of Arda:

One of the greatest Elves in the history of Middle-earth, Elrond was born at the Havens of Sirion late in the First Age. During their sack, he and his brother Elros were taken captive by the Sons of Fëanor, but Maglor took pity on them and released them. When they were rescued, Elrond was found playing in a cave beneath a waterfall, and so received his name.

Both of Elrond's parents were half-elven, and after the War of Wrath he was given a choice; whether to be counted amongst the kindred of Elves or of Men. He chose the Firstborn, and remained in Lindon with High King Gil-galad.

After the invasion of Eriador by Sauron in the mid-Second Age, Elrond founded a refuge there in a deep hidden valley; this was named Imladris, or Rivendell in the Common Speech. After Sauron's defeat by Tar-Minastir of Númenor, Elrond remained in Rivendell, where he prospered with the aid of the Great Ring, Vilya.

Elrond played a great part in the histories of the Second and Third Ages; he marched with Gil-galad and Elendil to the War of the Last Alliance, and was a leading member of the White Council. At the time of the Council of Elrond in 3018 (Third Age), he had dwelt in Middle-earth for some 6,500 years.
Notes
1 In a letter of 1958, Tolkien gives a very detailed derivation of Elrond. When the Sons of Fëanor attacked the Exiles of Gondolin, Elrond and his brother Elros (both at that time small children) were carried off, but later found near a waterfall; Elrond was discovered in a cave behind the fall - hence 'Elf of the Cave'. However, in a much later letter (1972), Tolkien interprets the name 'Vault of Stars', and Christopher Tolkien gives the similar 'Star-dome' in his Appendix to The Silmarillion. Whether it was Tolkien's intention to change the derivation of Elrond, or whether the older story simply slipped his mind, cannot now be known.

More correctly, Elves don't suffer ageing in the same way as Men. In fact they do age, as Tolkien makes clear in his Letters. There, he says, 'The Elves were sufficiently longeval to be called by Man 'immortal'. But they were not unageing or unwearying' (The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien No 245, dated 1963).

hey, hey, don't diss Hugo Weaving, i think that he's cool, and i don't think that he looks that old...

i wouldn't give the part of elrond to any one else! 😄

Hugo Weaving is Elrond! I honestly can't imagine anyone else playing Elrond. The movie would not have been the same without him.

Yes, yes, yes, he's very good as Elrond! But I still think he is too old: Eldarion does say (by the way thanks for all the cool info) : 'The Elves were sufficiently longeval to be called by Man 'immortal' But they were not unageing or unwearying'.
But Galadriel is so much older than Elrond, and she still looks young.

Galadriel looks older than Elrond to be. The only reason why Elrond looks old to anyone is because he's so wise and he's seen many many years.

No One Else Could Play Elrond, He Plays The Part So Well, I Wouldn't Want Any One Else Playing Him. It Just Wouldn't Be The Same, He Is So Hot As Elrond, And The Reason Why I Think He Looks Old , Is because He Has Been Through So Much, and Seen So Much, That It Has Taken A Toll On Him. He Is Also Wise Beyond His Years. I Absolutely Love Him Playing Elrond. 😍

😄 Hugo Weaving is the best person who could play Elrond to me...

Exactly, He is an amazing Elrond.

i really don't think that he looks that old anyway...

I kinda think he is cute, how bout you guys? 😉

Hugo Weaving? Uh... no thanks, but idk..

Aww come on, as an elf, he is cute, i don't know why, but he just is a cutie, lol

he could be cute...yeah..but i'll stick to my ringwraith friends here 😄

you do all know that if anyone else had played elrond youd be saying the same thing about him,

its just you cant imagine anyone else playing him,

yeah thats true too 😄 but it doesn't matter if different people play the ringwraiths, they'll always be my favorites! 😄

Orli is my fav, hands down

i don't know... sauron... that's why i don't think that he's too attractive, but its not like he's butt ugly *cough cough peter jackson cough cough*