Good Charlotte????

okay ive been here for a few days and already ive noticed there are quite a few Good Charlotte fans around. cmon Good Charlotte??? apparently they were good when they werent so poular, and ill believe that, but now they are just terrible. but the thing is some people actually think they're BETTER than some true (contempary)punk bands, like Jimmy Eat World. which is just strange. so heres a test to see how many people believe this. who is better, Good Charlotte ( 😘 ) or Jimmy Eat World ( 🤘 ) .

purely out of interest of course.

anyone who votes for GC needs a head check

Two socks! Are we stupid?

neither

GC.. i heard more of em thats why.....

I don't listen to Jimmy Eat World and I hate Good Charloette so I would have to say neither. C'mon, what kind of song is Lifestyles of the Rich and the Famous???

i dont like either band but my band nothing but losers and my firends band deem are writing a song called benji blow your brians out we are playing it this new years

Originally posted by Wolfie
I don't listen to Jimmy Eat World and I hate Good Charloette so I would have to say neither. C'mon, what kind of song is Lifestyles of the Rich and the Famous???

Same here. But I chose Jimmy Eat World anyway because no one can be worse than GC.

gc arent that bad some of their songs are reely good.
their songs have meaning. i havent heard jimmy eat world so im not gonna dis them.

Their songs have no meaning. "Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous"? "Girls Don't like Boys"? Yea, those are truly deep songs. GC sucks. Its all power chords and complaining about supid shit when they have no idea what they are talking about in the first place

I think Good Charlotte is pretty much a newer Green Day, only difference. I like Green Day's songs. An' as for Jimmy Eat World, I don't even listen to them so I have no opinion

GOOD CHARLOTTE ALL THE WAY! besides, jimmy eats world song "in the middle" was getting annoying.

They both suck!

havnt listened to Jimmy Eat World but i voted for them anyway coz GC suck sum mighty arse

I enjoyed 'Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous' but the rest of there outputs were pretty mundane and nothing special as for Jimmy Eat World there ok done one or two good songs but nothing too special.

GC is the only band worse than Linkin Park as far as i'm concerned.
lifestyle's and that other song are sooooo terrible. a retarded dog could come up with something more original. Jimmy doesn't get flamed by me cause i haven't heard them. if they sound anything like GC, then may God have mercy on their souls.

plenTpak52 you obviously havent listened to much of gc hav u? its a bit of a shame they released the two songs with the least meanin on the whole two albums but...thats life. every other song is. oh well. if people are too small minded to give gc a chance thats their choice. if i had a pound for everyone who sed they suck id have a loooot of pounds by now believe me. im still gonna defend em if no one else will.

i hope to fist fight with the guitarist one day just ti see if he could back his shit up

Benji? He would beat the shit out of you. He can definitely back his shit up, but he wouldn't waste his time with you. He's a great person, though. And a true punk. He doesn't give a damn what anybody says about him or his band. That's what punk is all about. He is the heart and soul of that band.

Jimmy Eat World are great, and "Bleed American" is a awesome song, but GC's first album is what got me into punk. You can say they aren't punk, and I don't give a damn what your opinion is, but they opened the door for me and I am eternally grateful and I will forever defend them. The first album was badass, the second was mediocre, with a few good songs, but I truly believe the next album(which is due out this year) will be great.

Claidisa....that's a great, GREAT point. Their first album was awesome, and the second album wasn't TOO bad, either. It just seems to me that it's cool now to make fun of Good Charlotte. What have they done wrong? Gotten rich playing music they want to, and working their way up from squatters to quasi rock stars? That's the way it should be. I'm with you...I will forever defend them, especially because they got me into punk, whether they're punk or not.