traitor

I got it, I got it!!!!!!!

The traitor is Anakin!!!!!!!
Well, actually, he IS (for a few hours) PHISICALLY in the JC in TPM
And he will be one of most prepared on sith stuff in the whole saga!!!!!

Why I can't get my fingers quiet???? they get the control of my keyboard and do stupid things!

yeah I know; just got that...

and may I say again that GL said that there was SOMEONE that knew that the Sith were rising? He didn't say:
Watch TPM again, there is a traitor in it.

in the tpm every one on the jc dissagree with gui gon when he says the sith have returned apart from 1 little green guy who says'hard to see the dark side is' its yoda who knows that there back

perhaps, but the one that knows it, could lie because perhaps he knows Sidious?

Where the heck did this idea come from that you need the Dark Side to see the future? Heck, ALL Jedi have a limited sense of the future! This is a nonsense idea.

The closest I have heard to it is that Dooku had a particular talent for future sense, and of course Dooku is a bad guy. But there is no DIRECT link between the two.

Meanwhile, a true traitor in the JC is unlikely, Windu's line in 'Choices' still confuses me, and you can make up any reason at all (within reason...) as to how the ship in TPM was traced but the fact is the film SHOULD have told us.

TPM DID tell us who sent the message. when obiwan tells them to send to message, the camera focuses on a member of amidala's group, i dont know the characters name. that was lucas's way of telling us

the fake queen and amidala? hard to belief!

That's not really telling us who did it in the traditional 'telling us who did it' sense of the word.

It was abundantly UNCLEAR how the trace was made.

i dont think anyone BETRAYED them to the sith. the fake queen simply wanted to know the status of her people, and thought ben was overreacting about a trace. that was my view of things, anyway

It is certainly possible. But it still should have been made clear.