General Question Thread

Started by sauron2 pages

*sigh* not the type of question i expected master andres,

I'm hurt that my question was looked over. But I shall recover. Luckily I looked it up in my book when I got home and all was not lost.

oh sorry, i apologise, two pages so far and only two sensible questions, *gets a noose*

why did my beautiful thread have to go on this way

I like the thread, but have no question. Read the books about 100 times and seen the movies almost that same amount, so sorry. But prepare yourself, I think after the third installement, they will bombard you......so keep it up...... 馃槃 馃槢

I echo that. I have no questions. But after the movie comes out there will be thousands of questions from non-bookies asking why this and why that. Ect. Ect. Ect.

U are gonna kill me if I keep posting w/o a question. 馃槜 馃槆

lol il forgive you, just i want some question, i mean you people cant know everything

I got another one, what lands did the Eastlings come from??

Dates: First recorded in the years after the Dagor Bragollach of I 4551
Race: Men
Division: Men of Darkness
Cultures: Numerous
Other names: Men of Darkness, Swarthy Men

A general name for the races of Men from the unknown East of Middle-earth, who were a constant foe of the Free Peoples, from the treachery of Ulfang in the Nirnaeth Arnoediad of the First Age to their frequent attacks against Gondor in the Third Age

ok

Oh I have many questions. I have only read LOTR and the Hobbit. I am now trying to work my way through the Sill. I am trying to answer my own questions but soon I will prob need clarification on some stuff. LOL

lol ok, im reading the sill too, im onto the war of wrath 馃槃

Who and how many elves remained in Middle Earth in the fourth age?

Ok something else about the Easterlings - the Easterlings from the First Age and those that appear during the Third Age (Balchoth, Wainriders and the Easterlings of Sauron in the War of the Ring) are most probably NOT the same.

While a part of the early Easterlings (B贸rs group) supported the Eldar, the others (Ulfangs people) betrayed the Elves, but before the Eldar also had trusted them.

The other Easterlings in the Third Age are "completely" evil and also came from an other region than those of the first age who had travelled through Beleriand and also lived there.

Who and how many? That's difficult to say as Tolkien doesnt give many names, but at least he states that C铆rdan and Celeborn were the last ancient elves that remained in Rivendell and had also lived during the First Age.
At the beginning of the Fourth Age, Elrond and Galadriel leave Middle-earth with most of their relatives and friends; afterwards, most Elves lived in "Eastern L贸rien" which includes parts of Mirkwood. Some also moved to Ithilien together with Legolas, who left Middle-earth together with Gimli.

Why didn't you do this earlier, Exa?

why didnt she do what?

Well now why would you say that the easterlings were completely evil? they were under the dominion of sauron, but remember what faramir/sam said about the southerner in ithilien. i would assume that the easterlings would be in the same spot, not truly evil but lied to and forced to go to war for sauron. ussually when i assume things i am way off but i'll say it all the same, lol.

see your point, also because of fear perhaps, i mean if sauron asks you to go to war and you have no allies you go to damn war

how many Easlings did go to war for sauron?? and for a side quastion, do u make dose cool signature pics your self sauron?馃檪

how many kinds of elves were there originaly?

no i got nazgulinthe dark to make them 馃槃