A Perfect Circle [merged]

great band..i just got thier new album "thirteenth step" amazing! maynards voice shines like allways..any other fans ?

APC = Good

I saw them at Voodoo Music Fest. They rocked. When they played 'The Nurse Who Loved Me' they had Troy (is that his name?) from Queens of the Stone Age come out and sit on stage. (QotSA were at Voodoo too.) They rocked. Maynard has a beautiful voice.

-Smitten Kitten-

*giddy* Perfect circle is awsome! I can't seem to take the new cd out of the player...ah i would love to see em live n_n

Their ok not amazing although their self titled debut album was pretty good.

thier one of the few listenable american bands these days..still i prefer tool..more complex and heavier

Can't stand Tool to be honest, Bad Religion are far better and totally underated great vocals, strong lyrics and great solos.

both bands are good in my opinion! but still i like tool a bit more then bad religion.

I cant see anything really appealing about Tool.

i understand..i just like the complex music they put togther in an original way and i like how maynard writes poems and turns them into music.

Let's see...thought-provoking lyrics that have many different levels, complex song structure that manages to be ingenuitive without being crap, Maynard's beautiful voice...in fact, I'm not sure what's *not* appealing about Tool.

I like Bad Religion.

I think I like Tool better than APC. It's harder and angrier.

-Smitten Kitten-

im a fan...i like the remix of weak and powerless and judith off of the underworld soundtrack...

ya the remix of weak of powerless is great!

these guys are amazing. they are pure quality rock, and Mer De Noms is a masterpiece. the song Rose is excellent, its almost beautiful. Maynard IS god.

yes yes i agreeee 8-) a perfect circle is awesome, it's the closest way to get to maynard since tool is done touring!

i seen them live ..

The difference is that APC is a superband, and when you get that many great musicians together, you can't possibly do anything wrong. Tool is really good, and the drummer is F*N awesome, but you can't compare Tool and APC because they are so different. I loved Mer De Noms, and I haven't heard much of 13th Step.

QOTSA...the singer? His name is Josh Homme. The bassists name is Nick Oliveri. That's the whole band. They got Dave Grohl to play drums.

nope SA your wrong about that troy van somthing or other was also in the band most people dont know but they also had three singers

I'm talking now...it's Josh and Nick.

comments?