Originally posted by ElvenQueen
It really doesnt have much to do with the story...if you think about it Fellowship of the Ring and Return of the King have alot more to do with the story than Two Towers...its kinda like wtf?
Well it is confusing
In the film, it is clearly stated : Orthanc and Barad-dur (everybody agrees on that, right?)
In the book, it is not specified, not clearly in the book, not by the publishers and not clearly by JRR Tolkien himself
The title was chosen by the publishers, not by JRR Tolkien. And the screenwriters of the film gave a meaning to it (otherwise it would be confusing for the public.
That contradicts, so no wonder it is confusing you.
For what I've read, Tolkien leaned more to Orthanc (book 3, Merry-Pippin-etc against Saruman) and Minas Morgul (book 4, Frodo-Sam against Shelob) (see covers) ... (book 3)
[Barad-dur is more present in The Return of the King imo]