dillema

what if...

you can have a role in SW, BUT you have to choos:

You can be a Jedi, with no lines, just a scene or two, three in the background
OR
an alien that has 10 lines????

Why, is Lucas offering you a contract? Obviously your talking about an actor who has to make a choice between the two, so who is it?

it's just:
WHAT IF, nobody that I know of has this happening now.
I want to know what your opinons are

Then I'd go with the role that had some lines.

Star Wars fans tend to memorize all the lines from a movie. If a character doesn't have a line, then he/she could be very forgettable. Look at me, I don't know the names of any of the Jedi concel, accept Yoda and Mace.

but the jedis tend to get in comics...

I'd go for the 10 lines!

i'd be a sith, darth sand person, nice ring to it.

Darth REX, King of the Sithly Robots.

Well, that wasn't one of the choices, smart guy.

I'de be an Alien with 10 lines.

and why?

alien, for the same reason as To

I would be a Jedi, fighting against a klone in the background

I'd be a Jedi as well.

It must be cool to have your own lightsabre, even for a few scenes!

Especially if you cut up a squad of droids and then die a noble death or got on the Jedi Council.

Quinlan Vos IS in EpI!!!!

Vos, Quinlan

Quinlan's character design came from a background extra glimpsed in Episode I, during the Mos Espa sequence that introduces Sebulba. Quinlan has starred in several story arcs of the ongoing Star Wars comic series from Dark Horse Comics.

Yeh, but if you were an extra with no lines, you are more likely to get cut than if you have lines, IHMO. Plus, as an alien, maybe you have a conversation with a Jedi as you lay dying. "Get him back for me, OB1...." Cool...

That would be cool. 🙂