Re: For Pippin Fans
Originally posted by Kitoky
Alittle something for Pippin Fans...
I don't understand why you like pippin so much for me he was the biggest waste of space from the three films!!! I found what parts he and merry had were extremly tireing and the only real part the had from the three films was acting as "a fake ring holder" to get some pressure off frodo!!!
Re: Re: For Pippin Fans
Originally posted by Cheeny
I don't understand why you like pippin so much for me he was the biggest waste of space from the three films!!! I found what parts he and merry had were extremly tireing and the only real part the had from the three films was acting as "a fake ring holder" to get some pressure off frodo!!!
Okie, PIPPIN FANS DON'T GO ON A MAD HUNT FOR CHEENY YET!!!!!!!!!!
1) Pippin is a great character in itself and there is more to him if you notice how he is in the book, you may or may not read them, but he plays a great role.
2) The casting of Pippin (Billy Boyd) played Pippin excellently and no one could probably be better.
3) If it weren't for Merry and Pippin, LotR probably would've lost alot of its fans because Merry and Pippin were basically Comic Relief for the crowd, and they're a great duo.
Everyone's entitled to their own opinion.
Re: Re: For Pippin Fans
Originally posted by Cheeny
I don't understand why you like pippin so much for me he was the biggest waste of space from the three films!!! I found what parts he and merry had were extremly tireing and the only real part the had from the three films was acting as "a fake ring holder" to get some pressure off frodo!!!
WHA-WHAT!!!! HOW!! WHY!!HOW COULD U SAY THAT!!!!!😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮 IM SHOCKED!!! PIPPIN IS SO NOT A WASTE OF TIME!!!! GEEZ READ THE TITAL "FOR PIPPIN FANS" IF U NOT A FAN THEN DONT RITE MEAN STUFF!!!!! 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠
Re: Re: Re: For Pippin Fans
Originally posted by Kitoky
Okie, PIPPIN FANS DON'T GO ON A MAD HUNT FOR CHEENY YET!!!!!!!!!!1) Pippin is a great character in itself and there is more to him if you notice how he is in the book, you may or may not read them, but he plays a great role.
2) The casting of Pippin (Billy Boyd) played Pippin excellently and no one could probably be better.
3) If it weren't for Merry and Pippin, LotR probably would've lost alot of its fans because Merry and Pippin were basically Comic Relief for the crowd, and they're a great duo.
Everyone's entitled to their own opinion.
As much as i also think people are entitled to their own opinion a feel u r reasons are not good enough. The second reason has nothin to do with it
maybe billy boyd is the the right man for the job that is not up for debate. However u say they r the comic relief. I BEG TO DIFER!!!! A have to honestly say hand on my heart i found gimli much funnier than pippin and merry. However i welcome a response from u and any other pippin fans!!
Re: Re: Re: For Pippin Fans
Originally posted by Melani
WHA-WHAT!!!! HOW!! WHY!!HOW COULD U SAY THAT!!!!!😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮 IM SHOCKED!!! PIPPIN IS SO NOT A WASTE OF TIME!!!! GEEZ READ THE TITAL "FOR PIPPIN FANS" IF U NOT A FAN THEN DONT RITE MEAN STUFF!!!!! 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠
K i understand mayb i shouldn't write in here but i am trying everyone in here that pippin isn't a massive character in the lotr stories and a did find myself fast forwarding these bits when i watch the dvds if it is just scenes with pippin and merry which annoyed me because i enjoyed the ents scene in the second film, a stroke of masterpiece by peter jackson!!! I am up for your response though!