KOTOR? Surprised to see that. it is a good game but it has design flaws.
I see all the games listed ar epretty darn modern; the furthest back being SMB1.
See, I would name Lords of Midnight from 1985 on any top list, if it is truly of 'All Time'. You would not believe how much that game revolutionised gaming.
Ledgend of Zelda: A Link To The Past (SNES)
Super Breakout (Atari)
Earthbound(SNES)
A Link To The Past Because it was the first zelda game I ever played and i'm still not sick of it.
Super Breakout may be old but it's wiked friggin addicting when competing with someone
Earthbound blew my mind away the first time i played it it still scares me how much i enjoy it