Philosophy Forum

What do you mean by 'too general', though? It is not as if Philosophical talk in there is swallowed up by discussion of other subjects. The GDF is the place for mature, sensible discussions- why seperate one such thing out of it?

It's a good thought in theory, I simply don't think it would work in actuallity. Too many people would get upset.

It is the great Kay that has in her sig:
you only fail when you stop trying ... try it before you say it will upset people

😱 I couldn' t agree more 😄

I think a philosophy forum would be great for KMC... if it doesn't work, it can still be closed again.

debates do belong in the gdf.....my vote is no

voted yes.

but i won't be ale to discuss philosophy in english 😛

I don't want a Philosophy forum. There won't be any good topics there. People won't be able to think just agree. No! there shouldn't be a Philosophy forum here!

*reverse psychology*

Reverse the reverse psychology 😉

Originally posted by BackFire
It's a good thought in theory, I simply don't think it would work in actuallity. Too many people would get upset.

When we discuss philosophy in the GDF, no one seems to get upset.

Originally posted by Storm
Reverse the reverse psychology 😉

But then I would be contradicting my original point. Which can cause a falacy in my statement. I'm sorry, but I can only discuss this in a Philosophical forum. 😉 😄

Originally posted by Dexx
debates do belong in the gdf.....my vote is no

see, storm, this is old school thinking... before we ended up having 150 other forums: everything goes to the GDF

Originally posted by yerssot
see, storm, this is old school thinking... before we ended up having 150 other forums: everything goes to the GDF

Well I, for one, am glad that the forum seems to have grown out of that thinking. Pitty it hasn't grown rar enough out of it for Raz to let us have a philosophy forum.

but than again, you're only here for 4 months

see... I'm not sure about dexx so I'll take me as example...
when I registered, you had Welcome, Q&A, GDF, two or three movie sections, the normal (minus Ep III) star wars sections (plus humor and trivia) and I think that was about it.
In those days when you wanted to talk about a book, you just HAD to post it in the GDF, there was no ROOM somewhere else.

and since everyone is about "when I first joined it was so much better" they want to change as little as possible, so they want stuff BACK to the GDF instead of making more sections

Originally posted by yerssot
but than again, you're only here for 4 months

But then again, I challange anyone to explain, in detail, why this should stop me from having a valid opinion on how many forums we should have.

you ripped it out of context

it was to show that you as someone who has been here for 4 mounths has a different opinion than someone who has been here for longer than a year, and see the GDF differently

Originally posted by yerssot
you ripped it out of context

it was to show that you as someone who has been here for 4 mounths has a different opinion than someone who has been here for longer than a year, and see the GDF differently

Oops. My bad.

But when I first came here, I had to dig through art threads to find threads on anime and manga; that was annoying. Now, I can just go to the anime forum, and it is good. By adding that forum, things were made easier at no discernable loss, and I didn't see anyone line up to announce that there was already a forum to discuss anime in. I don't see why this should be any different.

well, when you ask me, I don't see the use of making a seperate forum about it, I think that most threads are created cause now the room is given to it, but before there was a forum there were no threads clogging up another forum

that's how I see it 😉

yeah...there were fewer sections...there was the rp section besides what yerrs said, when i joined.....and it was more than ok....not needing to scroll down for every little insignifiant new section (of which there are plenty, nowadays 😉 )
guess the member no. huge increase has it's consequences....increase due to the otf.....biggest mistake ever...oh well.

a philosophy discussion simply blends into the gdf....it has to host something.....

"it will get rough pal, didn't want to speak for ya" 😉