Originally posted by aniron
Sorry guys, but I can't stand eowyn, but I'm sure Miranda's ok?
I think she beat the witch king through luck, and she only poked his face through the help of a titchy hobbit.
she is a man stealer and mopes the hell out of the film.
And arwens dresses are greater.
What is wuth eowyn standing and staring at nothing? the fool.
Okay thats my limited view, I'm goona stop there before I get into the details.
I resent that. Have you read the books? There is a lot unsaid about Eowyn, that, if it was said, would give more insight into the character. Eowyn is the human female in Lord of the Rings. I have nothing against Arwen, she's cool and everything, but she's to etherial to be real. I like Eowyn because she is independent and not afraid to stand up for herself. She didn't just kill the Witch-King by luck. She had the courage to stand up to him in the first place, that's got to count for something. She was defending her uncle.
Eowyn has an incredibly dark past, her parents both killed when she was 6, she watched her uncle and cousin die and she had to put up with Grima for 10 yrs. You'd feel sorry for her too. Cut the poor girl some slack.
Miranda's great too. My friend knows her, and just saw her last holidays. She said that she's so sweet and down-to-earth. She got bruises from that helmet she had to wear.
You are entitled to your opinion, but please find a better reason for hating her.
Originally posted by Shieldmaiden
I resent that. Have you read the books? There is a lot unsaid about Eowyn, that, if it was said, would give more insight into the character. Eowyn is the human female in Lord of the Rings. I have nothing against Arwen, she's cool and everything, but she's to etherial to be real. I like Eowyn because she is independent and not afraid to stand up for herself. She didn't just kill the Witch-King by luck. She had the courage to stand up to him in the first place, that's got to count for something. She was defending her uncle.Eowyn has an incredibly dark past, her parents both killed when she was 6, she watched her uncle and cousin die and she had to put up with Grima for 10 yrs. You'd feel sorry for her too. Cut the poor girl some slack.
Miranda's great too. My friend knows her, and just saw her last holidays. She said that she's so sweet and down-to-earth. She got bruises from that helmet she had to wear.
You are entitled to your opinion, but please find a better reason for hating her.
you said it all 😎
basically, Eowyn rocks
Originally posted by aniron
Sorry guys, but I can't stand eowyn, but I'm sure Miranda's ok?
I think she beat the witch king through luck, and she only poked his face through the help of a titchy hobbit.
she is a man stealer and mopes the hell out of the film.
And arwens dresses are greater.
What is wuth eowyn standing and staring at nothing? the fool.
Okay thats my limited view, I'm goona stop there before I get into the details.
Uuuuhhh....I'll just post what you posted in your own thread I don't
Originally posted by aniron
ok to make this clear, this thread is for non eowyn fans like sauron -yey- I can see why ppl don't see a point but I don't really care if you like eowyn don't come into the thread. simple.
I'll just give your remark back to you.
ok to make this clear, this thread is for eowyn fans like Exa -yey-I can see why ppl don't see a point but I don't really care if you don't like eowyn don't come into the thread. simple.
There....fair?! 🙄 I suggest you practice first before you preach. You posted that remark in your thread, telling people who like Eowyn to back off, but in an Eowyn thread, you're going in just to rant how much you don't like her and comment about her so-called flaws? 🙄
I also like Arwen and all, but don't even get me started with her own flaws that you yourself don't even see, I just didn't posted them in your own thread because I respected your thread, I know it's for the Eowyn non-fans, and I knew that, that's why I didn't degrade Arwen in anyway in that thread or forced anyone to love Eowyn just because I love Eowyn more than her. You on the other hand, is doing the opposite thing.
Sorry...can't resist, and I'm bored..But let's go over this one by one shall we!? 😄
I think she beat the witch king through luck, and she only poked his face through the help of a titchy hobbit.
she is a man stealer
and mopes the hell out of the film.
And arwens dresses are greater.
What is wuth eowyn standing and staring at nothing? the fool.
Okay thats my limited view, I'm goona stop there before I get into the details.
Thanks, Iirima. 🙂
I'm just too sick of ignoring posts like this so other people consider them as facts, and so more people are being persuaded that Eowyn is nothing but a ***** which in all certainty, she's not. I liked Arwen's role in the movie but still I have some problems with her but I don't go on ranting in Arwen threads just to criticize her. I know everyone has their own rights to like whoever they want, and I don't get it why you have to pin-point all their flaws in a thread that actually likes the character. Are you trying to "convert" some fans to idolize your favorite character? I just don't get it. And if ever you have some problems with the character, please make your post as a constructive criticism, not just pointing your problems and calling names and stating them like they are facts. It's misleading dude, and a disgrace for the character itself, especially for those who are just newbies in the world of Middle-earth.
OK...this is my reply to the thread itself. As you all know that I love Eowyn.
Eowyn had a great book to film adaptation, and was wonderfully played by Miranda Otto. Eowyn was the strongest woman in the films, as she is in the books in my opinion, and the lack of romance made her even more so, though it made her feelings seem untrue and not finished business. After the extended edition we will see a new side of the Eowyn adaptation, and I'm hoping that we will see a new side of her through The Houses of Healing scenes. 🙂