Who's the best Vala?

Started by Smodden3 pages

Tulkas!Tulkas!Tulkas!

Originally posted by Exa
*cries* no Melkor
😛

I voted for Nienna cuy shes a great character and nearly nobody ever mentions her

As much as I like her, she's too depressing. 🙁 Always crying, The Silmarillion is a very depressing book already. 🙁

yeah my book is dreanched with tears🙁

Originally posted by Aurora
I am trying now for the third time to read the Sil. Everytime I would pick it up before I got distracted.... I am doing really good right now....... I am still at the begining tho...... I don't want anyone to die!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You have to prepare yourself already. 😛 And be careful when you're attaching yourself too much to a certain character because there's an 85% chance that he's gonna die.

I remember when I attached myself too much to

Spoiler:
Fingolfin and Turin
, I broke down when they died. 🙁 I almost can't sleep for 3 nights. 🙁

Don't say I didn't put a spoiler tag. 😛

Originally posted by MorgulLord
I tried reading it once but got bored on the second page? is it just me or has it all got something to do with Music??

You certainly should go past the second page to destroy your boredom. 😛 It's not just all about the Music of the Ainur, well yeah..the first couple of pages are because it's an account of their Music to create Ea, but once you get through it, and started reading Valaquenta and all else that follows, all the adventures and informations are exciting and you feel like you're really there. 😄

EDIT: nevermind what I posted. 😉

voted Yavanna, but almost voted for orome, he rides a white horse and guided the elves

those two died, oh well, haven't gotten that far yet, but i did see the spoiler, my fault, well just in case i don't get that far... i do find it hard to concentrate with that book

Yay another vote for Yavanna~~!!!!! I am not alone!!!!

Dude! Manwe is hated! Not that I mind, (he's boring as hell) 😛 I'm the only one who voted for him just because of his power. I should have voted for Orome now that I'm in a better mind. 🙁 He's far waayy cooler than Manwe. 🙁

Since Melkor is not counted among the Valar I will say this: "Manwë and Melkor were brethren in the thought of Ilúvatar. The mightiest of those Ainur who came into the world was in his beginning Melkor; but Manwë is dearest to Ilúvatar and understands most clearly his purposes. Ulmo is the Lord of Waters…He is next in might to Manwë. Aulë has might little less than Ulmo". In short…sorry for that tidbit…Manwë is the mightiest even if Tulkas is greatest in strength and deeds.

Yeah..that's what I was saying. Manwe is really powerful, that's why I voted for him, but really I don't like him. But I don't like Tulkas either. 😛 My favorite Valar are Ulmo and Orome. 😄

I agree, Manwë seems to do pretty much nothing but delegate. And Tulkas, he sort of reminds of the Viking god Thôr, not much on personality but great on attitude. I vote for Manwë, but he is not my favorite. Aulë would be mine, for he unknowingly set in motion the sorrow of the Noldor when he taught Mahtan many skills who in turn taught Fëanor…and so the story goes.

Yeah, Aule's cool too. 😄 Making the Dwarves and all. He has his own will though he's not Evil and really didn't want to compete with Eru. 😄 And like sauron said, Saruman and Sauron were his Maiars first, so...😍

*theme song to XFiles plays*...conspiracy?...hmmm...coincedence?

Maybe Saruman and Sauron are already buddies before and they have some plans unknown to others but I don't think our dear Aule has something to do with it. ❌ I think it's just a coincidence for his part that that they were both his Maiar. 🙁

Most definitely Aulë was ignorant of the fact…But I think Sauron may have enticed Saruman after he himself was enticed by Melkor and kept it all hush-hush. Maybe Saruman then agreed to be in league with Sauron and Melkor from the start, but wasn’t stupid just yet and waited to see the fruits of Melkor’s labor before announcing his true loyalty to whatever outcome.

Here’s something to think about…hehe…if you take Saruman’s name, move the ‘u’ to where the ‘r’ is and put the ‘r’ where the ‘u’ was, then change the ‘ma’ to an ‘o’, what’ve you got…hmmmm
😖hifty:

Sauron. 😛

I heard that's also one of the reasons why in the animated LOTR, Saruman is called Aruman, they don't want to pronounce the S because they said Sauron and Saruman sound alike. 😄

And yeah, bastard Saruman, cunning and all. He's really wise. I'm wondering though if Sauron and Saruman are naturally arrogant and aggresive and "evil" inside their hearts already even before Melkor seduced them or were they just really corrupted? 😛

Lol

I also like Ulmo, apart from Melkor he's the only one who really cares for middleearth's peoples and helps them (or not 😄 )

I was between Manwe and Ulmo... I like them both, but as I am a sea-freak... I chose Ulmo ✅

😄

I think its a little stupid that Manwe was the lord of the valar i mean the others did far more things... only cuz ilú thought he might be mighty.....