Who is the greatest sith we've seen in action?

look at his fingers, he attempts to lift him, then collapses his hand in defeat. this is the first seed of returning to the light in him. he realizes that even with the dark side, he cannot save everyone, and even ends up hurting those he loves. (gee, he should have realized that with padme 23 1/2 years earlier)

Originally posted by Red Superfly
^^^^ Since when did he do that?

He was just holding out his arm as a gesture.

That's how I took it as well. It doesn't really appear to me that he was ever trying to bring Luke up from his fall.

It's far too quick a gesture for him to be trying to lift Luke. If it were the case it'd totally dimish the impact of Vader watching his son being electricuted and making the final decision to redeem himself.

Man talk about over-analysing a scene too much. 🙄

vader was holding his hand to luke, trying to get luke to join him. when luke fell, vader lowered his hand in a "oh well" gesture. there was no attempt at force lifting.

Originally posted by Red Superfly
Um, yes it does.

.

Perhaps I should clarify. Force choking a few Imperial admarials, especially if they are not force users..........