Vader Breathing In Episode II

I was watching Episode II on HBO a few days ago, and for the first time I thought I heard classic Vader breathing in one of the scenes. I don't know is this is old news or not, but I would like to know if anyone else noticed it as well.

What scene was it?

Originally posted by amity75
What scene was it?

Check the scene in which Yoda is meditating and sensing Anakin is in "terrible pain". Yoda hears voices and just after "Anakin, No!" I thought I caught one cycle of Vader's breathing. If Yoda is able to sense things that have happened and are currently happing, is it possible he might have some premonition of things to come?

You my friend are 100% absolutely, positively correct!

I cant believe after 100 times of seeing the film I still missed it!
Thank you!!

Rolda

I actually have that sequence on my PC... uploaded....

it could be with good will the exhalation (sp) of Vader, but not an entire breething

the "anakin, no" is actualy qui gons voice

yup, though the "no" part was not Liam who said it

I was going to make a thread on this the other day, I saw it on HBO too, and noticed an exhaling as Yoda was meditating. But clouded the future is.

i just watched it, and there is a definite difference between the two voices. the one saying "anakin" is qui gon, but the one saying "no" is someone else. also, there is the vader heavy breathing as the word "no" is uttered. the statement that yoda makes is, "pain...suffering...death" (or something to that effect). then he states that anakin is in terrible pain. is it possible that he is seeing into the future when anakin becomes vader? could it be that yoda is speaking of two separate events, not just shmi's death, but possibly padme's? or even anakin's death of his former self? is that why qui gon is speaking, because of this future event? is it actually vader speaking while he is physically becoming vader? (grasping for straws, maybe) watching that scene in this light is perplexing. i'm hoping that lucas wrote it that way. if not, we may be putting too much into this.

as you can tell, i'm impaitiently waiting for episode III

madsci

Not sure what this scene is. I mean I just thought Yoda was visualizing Ani's pain from his mom dying.

it's the same scene, i just wanted to put down in writing the thoughts/questions that were in my head. like i said, i may be putting too much into it though.

madsci

Originally posted by speiderman
Not sure what this scene is. I mean I just thought Yoda was visualizing Ani's pain from his mom dying.

Yoda couldn't specifically know to visualize Anakin's mother death. Yoda simply "opened" himself and meditated on the force and Anakin. What came through seemed like dark events.

yerssot, which player do i need to listen to that clip? ive tried windows media, real player and divx, no luck

unzip it first than take any player that supports mp3

OK, I'm stretching here, but could the "no" be Anakin's alleged scream when her hears Padme is dead? Just a thought.

The nooooo part sounds like yoda saying it...didnt find this a mystery

I saw the same on HBO but couldn't post it because the Internet was out for 5 days if it wasn't i would of posted it the same way but thanks fore the thread i had a felling some one here heard it also. 💃

the "no" is hayden

one other thing, watch chapter 19 of clone wars and listen to the water dripping inside the massassi temple. same tone as vader's breathing.

if I'm not mistaken, the "no" is from QGJ, but have to check the book

I'm pretty sure who says the Qui Gon part isn't the point here.

There is defintely Vader breathing there. Thanks for sharing that 😄