if you were a genie...

If you were a genie, and someone asked you this wish: "I wish that you would not grant me this wish". WHAT WOULD YOU DO?

I'd do absolelty nothing 😕

but by doing nothing you are granting his wish, and ur not supposed to

fulfill the wish by doing nothing
he ask to get a wish less, so that's what he should get

doesn't matter if you say you grant the wish or not, you as a genie have to obey him by not granting it that's his wish

But by doing that, you are breaking the bond of disobeying the masters commands. By not granting the wish, you are granting his wish.

It is an answerless question

what are you disobeying exactly? he asks not to grant it, you follow it by not granting it, that's the wish he want

Originally posted by surf_bunny86
but by doing nothing you are granting his wish, and ur not supposed to

no kruffing kidding, thats why you asked this stupid question. If I was in that situation, I'd do nothing or say "I'm not the kind of genie who can grant that wish."

Oh wait a second! 😱 I'm NOT a genie! Why should I care? 🙄

would live in my pimped out bottle and tell who ever came a rubben to go blow it! 😛

If I were a genie I'd tell them to go away, I'm the one with the cool genie powers

I have a very active Imagination and I have been thinking about this Situation For Many years. If I had a Genie I would wish that I could reach into any tv or picture and make any item I grab real and pull them out. Think ABOUT THE POSSIBILITIES! Tell me how that's not a good wish.

😑 ........ 😑 Trick question!

just dont do nething, ur fulfilling the question, he asked you not to complete the wish, and by doing nothing your not completing it, therefore obeying ur master 😉

either that or id slap him

hmmmmm

If I was a genie I would get my self a house instead of living in a lamp!

Originally posted by Df02
just dont do nething, ur fulfilling the question, he asked you not to complete the wish, and by doing nothing your not completing it, therefore obeying ur master 😉

But by doing nothing, you grant the wish, and you were requested by your master not to. Therefore, you cannot do anything. Here is another example of the same type of question:

"A town decided one day to prohibit lying. Anybody who was caught lying was to be hanged immediately. One man, who had been honest his entire life, went to the cop shop and said, "I am about to be hanged for lying to you." "

He is lying, and therefore should be hanged. However, if they hang him, he would be telling the thruth.

id still hang him, because he sounds like a ***

Well he wished it so there you don't do anything 1 wish down 2 to go

🙁 I wish for world Peace....

i dont, without violence theres no fear of consequence...Oo

Originally posted by spudly23
Well he wished it so there you don't do anything 1 wish down 2 to go

He wished the wish was not granted. So how can you grant that wish? Thus, 3 wishes left.

It is impossible to answer. You could argue this til the 'cows come home,' and there still would be no resolution.

If I were a genie, and someone wished that, I'd slap him.